Vaccine Rollout Task Force, Public Health Agency of Canada, Ottawa, ON, KIA 0K9, Canada.
Vaccine Rollout Task Force, Public Health Agency of Canada, Ottawa, ON, KIA 0K9, Canada.
Vaccine. 2023 May 2;41(18):2932-2940. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.03.040. Epub 2023 Apr 3.
In 2021, the ten provinces in Canada enacted COVID-19 vaccine mandates that restricted access to non-essential businesses and services to those that could provide proof of full vaccination to decrease the risk of transmission and provide an incentive for vaccination. This analysis aims to examine the effects of vaccine mandate announcements on vaccine uptake over time by age group and province.
Aggregated data from the Canadian COVID-19 Vaccination Coverage Surveillance System (CCVCSS) were used to measure vaccine uptake (defined as the weekly proportion of individuals who received at least one dose) among those 12 years and older following the announcement of vaccination requirements. We performed an interrupted time series analysis using a quasi-binomial autoregressive model adjusted for the weekly number of new COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations, and deaths to model the effect of mandate announcements on vaccine uptake. Additionally, counterfactuals were produced for each province and age group to estimate vaccine uptake without mandate implementation.
The times series models demonstrated significant increases in vaccine uptake following mandate announcement in BC, AB, SK, MB, NS, and NL. No trends in the effect of mandate announcements were observed by age group. In AB and SK, counterfactual analysis showed that announcement were followed by 8 % and 7 % (310,890 and 71,711 people, respectively) increases in vaccination coverage over the following 10 weeks. In MB, NS, and NL, there was at least a 5 % (63,936, 44,054, and 29,814 people, respectively) increase in coverage. Lastly, BC announcements were followed by a 4 % (203,300 people) increase in coverage.
Vaccine mandate announcements could have increased vaccine uptake. However, it is difficult to interpret this effect within the larger epidemiological context. Effectiveness of the mandates can be affected by pre-existing levels of uptake, hesitancy, timing of announcements and local COVID-19 activity.
2021 年,加拿大的 10 个省份颁布了 COVID-19 疫苗授权令,限制了未接种疫苗人群进入非必要商业和服务场所的权利,以降低传播风险并为接种疫苗提供激励。本分析旨在按年龄组和省份,考察疫苗授权令发布对疫苗接种率随时间变化的影响。
使用来自加拿大 COVID-19 疫苗接种覆盖监测系统(CCVCSS)的汇总数据,衡量在宣布接种要求后,12 岁及以上人群的疫苗接种率(定义为每周至少接种一剂的个体比例)。我们使用拟二项式自回归模型进行了中断时间序列分析,该模型根据每周新 COVID-19 病例、住院和死亡人数进行了调整,以模拟授权令对疫苗接种率的影响。此外,还为每个省份和年龄组生成了反事实情况,以估计在没有实施授权令的情况下的疫苗接种率。
在 BC、AB、SK、MB、NS 和 NL,授权令发布后,疫苗接种率呈显著上升趋势。按年龄组观察到授权令发布对疫苗接种率的影响没有趋势。在 AB 和 SK,反事实分析表明,在接下来的 10 周内,公告发布后疫苗接种覆盖率分别增加了 8%(310,890 人)和 7%(71,711 人)。在 MB、NS 和 NL,覆盖率至少增加了 5%(63,936、44,054 和 29,814 人)。最后,BC 的公告发布后,疫苗接种覆盖率增加了 4%(203,300 人)。
疫苗授权令的发布可能增加了疫苗接种率。然而,在更大的流行病学背景下,很难解释这种影响。授权令的有效性可能受到先前接种率、犹豫、公告时间和当地 COVID-19 活动的影响。