Bragard Claude, Baptista Paola, Chatzivassiliou Elisavet, Di Serio Francesco, Gonthier Paolo, Jaques Miret Josep Anton, Justesen Annemarie Fejer, MacLeod Alan, Magnusson Christer Sven, Milonas Panagiotis, Navas-Cortes Juan A, Parnell Stephen, Potting Roel, Reignault Philippe Lucien, Stefani Emilio, Thulke Hans-Hermann, van der Werf Wopke, Yuen Jonathan, Zappalà Lucia, Makowski David, Crotta Matteo, Maiorano Andrea, Pautasso Marco, Vicent Civera Antonio
EFSA J. 2023 May 3;21(5):e08005. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2023.8005. eCollection 2023 May.
Following a request from the European Commission, the EFSA Panel on Plant Health performed a risk assessment of the citrus fruit midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae), an oligophagous species, which feeds on fruits of spp., and is reported from China. The pest was temporarily regulated in October 2022 (Regulation (EU) 2022/1941, under Art. 30 (2016/2031)). The entry risk assessment focused on the citrus fruit pathway. Three scenarios were considered: A0 (current practice, i.e. regulated pest for the EU), A1 (deregulation) and A2 (A0 with additional stand-alone post-harvest cold treatment). Based on the outputs of the entry model, under scenario A0, slightly less than 40 potential founder populations per year are expected (median; 90%-uncertainty interval between about one per 30 years and about 3,000 per year). Under scenario A1, the risk of entry increases by about three times and reaches about 120 potential founder populations per year (median; 90%-uncertainty interval between about one per 10 years and about 9,000 per year). Compared to scenario A0, the risk of entry is orders of magnitude lower for scenario A2 (median = about one potential founder population per 120 years; 90%-uncertainty interval between one per about 600 million years and about two per year). The main uncertainties in the entry assessment are the probability of transfer, the RRO effectiveness (for scenario A2) and the disaggregation of consignments (transport of citrus fruit in boxes or lots to different locations). For all scenarios, the number of established populations is only slightly lower than the number of potential founder populations. Establishment is thus not expected to be a major constraint for this pest to then spread and cause impacts, despite the uncertainty about the pest thermal requirements. The median lag period between establishment and spread is estimated to be about 18 months (90%-uncertainty interval between about 7 and 54 months). After the lag period, the median rate of spread by flying and due to transport of harvested citrus fruit from orchards to packinghouses is estimated at about 100 km/year (90%-range between about 40 and 500 km/year). The main uncertainties in the spread assessment include the level of susceptibility of cultivars of different citrus species in the EU, the spread rate in China and the climate suitability of the initial spread focus in the EU. The median impact of in the EU citrus-growing area (proportion of infested citrus fruit out of harvested citrus fruit) is estimated at about 10% (90%-uncertainty interval between about 2% and 25%). Uncertainties affecting the impact assessment include the susceptibility of different citrus cultivars and the effect of the citrus fruit-harvesting season in the EU (mainly winter, the less suitable season for the pest).
应欧盟委员会的要求,欧洲食品安全局植物健康专家组对柑橘实蝇(双翅目:瘿蚊科)进行了风险评估。柑橘实蝇是一种寡食性物种,以柑橘属果实为食,有来自中国的报告。该有害生物于2022年10月受到临时管制(欧盟法规(EU)2022/1941,第30条(2016/2031))。入境风险评估聚焦于柑橘类水果途径。考虑了三种情景:A0(当前做法,即欧盟的管制有害生物)、A1(解除管制)和A2(A0加上额外的独立收获后冷藏处理)。根据入境模型的输出结果,在情景A0下,预计每年潜在的奠基种群略少于40个(中位数;90%不确定性区间在约每30年1个和约每年300个之间)。在情景A1下,入境风险增加约三倍,达到每年约120个潜在奠基种群(中位数;90%不确定性区间在约每10年1个和约每年900个之间)。与情景A0相比,情景A2的入境风险低几个数量级(中位数=约每120年1个潜在奠基种群;90%不确定性区间在约每6亿年1个和约每年2个之间)。入境评估中的主要不确定性是转移概率、收获后处理措施的有效性(情景A2)以及货物的拆分(柑橘类水果以箱或批量运输到不同地点)。对于所有情景,已建立种群的数量仅略低于潜在奠基种群的数量。因此,尽管有害生物的热需求存在不确定性,但预计定殖不会成为该有害生物扩散并造成影响的主要限制因素。定殖与扩散之间的中位滞后期估计约为18个月(90%不确定性区间在约7至54个月之间)。滞后期过后,通过飞行以及由于收获的柑橘类水果从果园运输到包装厂导致的扩散速度估计约为每年100公里(90%范围在约40至500公里/年之间)。扩散评估中的主要不确定性包括欧盟不同柑橘品种的易感性水平、在中国的扩散速度以及欧盟初始扩散焦点地区的气候适宜性。柑橘实蝇在欧盟柑橘种植区造成的中位影响(收获的柑橘类水果中受侵染的柑橘类水果比例)估计约为10%(90%不确定性区间在约2%至25%之间)。影响评估中的不确定性包括不同柑橘品种的易感性以及欧盟柑橘收获季节(主要是冬季,对该有害生物不太适宜的季节)的影响。