Friedman L A, Kimball A W
Am J Epidemiol. 1986 Sep;124(3):481-9. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a114418.
The relationship between ethanol consumption and coronary heart disease was examined in the original Framingham Heart Study cohort (1948) with a 24-year follow-up from exam 2 (2,106 males and 2,639 females). Ethanol consumption shows a strong U-shaped relationship with coronary heart disease mortality for male nonsmokers and heavy smokers both in the raw age-adjusted data and in the Cox regression analyses, where ethanol consumption is modeled quadratically. No ethanol effects were found for female nonsmokers. The age-adjusted data suggest a U-shape curve for female smokers, although this was not confirmed by the Cox analysis. Separate analyses relating alcohol consumption to mortality from all causes showed similar effects except that the reduction in mortality for males was much less. For male coronary heart disease mortality, ethanol consumption was subdivided into beer, wine, and spirits consumption. These beverages were also modeled quadratically in the Cox analyses, and all showed strong U-shaped curves for both nonsmokers and heavy smokers. In nonsmokers, beer and wine show greater reductions in coronary heart disease mortality than spirits.
在最初的弗明汉心脏研究队列(1948年)中,对24年随访期内的第二次检查(2106名男性和2639名女性)进行了乙醇摄入量与冠心病之间关系的研究。在原始的年龄调整数据以及乙醇摄入量采用二次模型的Cox回归分析中,男性不吸烟者和重度吸烟者的乙醇摄入量与冠心病死亡率呈现出强烈的U型关系。未发现女性不吸烟者有乙醇效应。年龄调整数据表明女性吸烟者呈U型曲线,尽管Cox分析未证实这一点。将酒精摄入量与全因死亡率相关的单独分析显示了类似的效应,只是男性死亡率的降低幅度要小得多。对于男性冠心病死亡率,乙醇摄入量被细分为啤酒、葡萄酒和烈酒摄入量。在Cox分析中,这些饮品也采用二次模型,并且对于不吸烟者和重度吸烟者均呈现出强烈的U型曲线。在不吸烟者中,啤酒和葡萄酒对冠心病死亡率的降低作用大于烈酒。