Department of Health Policy and Management, Fielding School of Public Health, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Laboratory of Innovation Science at Harvard, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2023 Oct;38(13):2888-2897. doi: 10.1007/s11606-023-08294-1. Epub 2023 Jul 17.
Engaging frontline clinicians and staff in quality improvement is a promising bottom-up approach to transforming primary care practices. This may be especially true in federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) and similar safety-net settings where large-scale, top-down transformation efforts are often associated with declining worker morale and increasing burnout. Innovation contests, which decentralize problem-solving, can be used to involve frontline workers in idea generation and selection.
We aimed to describe the ideas that frontline clinicians and staff suggested via organizational innovation contests in a national sample of 54 FQHCs.
Innovation contests solicited ideas for improving care from all frontline workers-regardless of professional expertise, job title, and organizational tenure and excluding those in senior management-and offered opportunities to vote on ideas.
A total of 1,417 frontline workers across all participating FQHCs generated 2,271 improvement opportunities.
We performed a content analysis and organized the ideas into codes (e.g., standardization, workplace perks, new service, staff relationships, community development) and categories (e.g., operations, employees, patients).
Ideas from frontline workers in participating FQHCs called attention to standardization (n = 386, 17%), staffing (n = 244, 11%), patient experience (n = 223, 10%), staff training (n = 145, 6%), workplace perks (n = 142, 6%), compensation (n = 101, 5%), new service (n = 92, 4%), management-staff relationships (n = 82, 4%), and others. Voting results suggested that staffing resources, standardization, and patient communication were key issues among workers.
Innovation contests generated numerous ideas for improvement from the frontline. It is likely that the issues described in this study have become even more salient today, as the COVID-19 pandemic has had devastating impacts on work environments and health/social needs of patients living in low-resourced communities. Continued work is needed to promote learning and information exchange about opportunities to improve and transform practices between policymakers, managers, and providers and staff at the frontlines.
让一线临床医生和员工参与质量改进是一种有前途的自下而上的方法,可以改变基层医疗实践。这在联邦合格的健康中心 (FQHC) 和类似的安全网环境中可能尤其如此,在这些环境中,大规模的自上而下的转型努力往往与工人士气下降和倦怠加剧有关。创新竞赛可以分散解决问题,从而让一线员工参与想法的产生和选择。
我们旨在描述通过全国 54 个 FQHC 中的一个全国性样本中,一线临床医生和员工通过组织创新竞赛提出的想法。
创新竞赛向所有一线员工(无论专业知识、职称和组织任期如何,均不包括高级管理人员)征求改善护理的想法,并为投票提供机会。
共有 1417 名来自所有参与 FQHC 的一线员工提出了 2271 项改进机会。
我们进行了内容分析,并将这些想法组织成代码(例如,标准化、工作场所津贴、新服务、员工关系、社区发展)和类别(例如,运营、员工、患者)。
参与 FQHC 的一线员工的想法引起了对标准化(n=386,17%)、人员配备(n=244,11%)、患者体验(n=223,10%)、员工培训(n=145,6%)、工作场所津贴(n=142,6%)、薪酬(n=101,5%)、新服务(n=92,4%)、管理层与员工关系(n=82,4%)和其他问题的关注。投票结果表明,员工资源、标准化和患者沟通是员工关注的关键问题。
创新竞赛从一线产生了许多改进的想法。随着 COVID-19 大流行对工作环境和生活在资源匮乏社区的患者的健康/社会需求造成毁灭性影响,今天描述的这些问题可能变得更加突出。需要继续努力,促进决策者、管理人员和提供者以及一线员工之间关于改进和转型实践机会的学习和信息交流。