Centre for Research on Pandemics & Society; Consumption Research Norway, Oslo Metropolitan University, P.O. Box 4, St Olavs Plass, Oslo, 0130, Norway.
BMC Public Health. 2023 Jul 18;23(1):1377. doi: 10.1186/s12889-023-16236-z.
Self-perceived exposure risk determines the likelihood of COVID-19 preventive measure compliance to a large extent and is among the most important predictors of mental health problems. Therefore, there is a need to systematically identify important predictors of such risks. This study aims to provide insight into forecasting and understanding risk perceptions and help to adjust interventions that target various social groups in different pandemic phases.
This study was based on survey data collected from 5001 Norwegians in 2020 and 2021. Interpretable machine learning algorithms were used to predict perceived exposure risks. To detect the most important predictors, the models with best performance were chosen based on predictive errors and explained variances. Shapley additive values were used to examine individual heterogeneities, interpret feature impact and check interactions between the key predictors.
Gradient boosting machine exhibited the best model performance in this study (2020: RMSE=.93, MAE=.74, RSQ=.22; 2021: RMSE=.99, MAE=.77, RSQ=.12). The most influential predictors of perceived exposure risk were compliance with interventions, work-life conflict, age and gender. In 2020, work and occupation played a dominant role in predicting perceived risks whereas, in 2021, living and behavioural factors were among the most important predictors. Findings show large individual heterogeneities in feature importance based on people's sociodemographic backgrounds, work and living situations.
The findings provide insight into forecasting risk groups and contribute to the early detection of vulnerable people during the pandemic. This is useful for policymakers and stakeholders in developing timely interventions targeting different social groups. Future policies and interventions should be adapted to the needs of people with various life situations.
自我感知的暴露风险在很大程度上决定了 COVID-19 预防措施的遵守程度,是心理健康问题最重要的预测因素之一。因此,需要系统地确定这些风险的重要预测因素。本研究旨在深入了解风险感知的预测和理解,并帮助调整针对不同大流行阶段的各种社会群体的干预措施。
本研究基于 2020 年和 2021 年从 5001 名挪威人收集的调查数据。使用可解释的机器学习算法来预测感知暴露风险。为了检测最重要的预测因素,根据预测误差和解释方差选择表现最佳的模型。Shapley 加法值用于检测个体异质性、解释特征影响并检查关键预测因素之间的交互作用。
在本研究中,梯度提升机表现出最佳的模型性能(2020 年:RMSE=.93,MAE=.74,RSQ=.22;2021 年:RMSE=.99,MAE=.77,RSQ=.12)。感知暴露风险的最具影响力的预测因素是干预措施的遵守情况、工作与生活的冲突、年龄和性别。2020 年,工作和职业在预测感知风险方面发挥了主导作用,而在 2021 年,生活和行为因素是最重要的预测因素之一。研究结果表明,基于人们的社会人口背景、工作和生活状况,特征重要性存在很大的个体异质性。
这些发现为预测风险群体提供了深入的了解,并有助于在大流行期间早期发现弱势群体。这对制定针对不同社会群体的及时干预措施的政策制定者和利益相关者很有用。未来的政策和干预措施应适应具有各种生活状况的人们的需求。