Di Piazza Giulio, Dujardin Bruno, Levorato Sara, Medina Paula, Mohimont Luc, Solazzo Efisio, Costanzo Violetta
EFSA J. 2024 Feb 8;22(2):e8554. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2024.8554. eCollection 2024 Feb.
Aiming at accelerating the implementation of cumulative risk assessment to pesticide residues, this report describes a two-step prioritisation analysis, on individual pesticides and on target organ systems, that allows to identify (i) low-priority substances expected to have a marginal contribution to cumulative risk, and (ii) high priority organ systems to be addressed in future cumulative risk assessments. The analysis encompassed 350 substances and 36 raw primary commodities of plant origin surveyed in the monitoring cycle 2019-2021, carried out in 30 population groups, covering 3 age classes, and 17 EU countries. Probabilistic exposure calculations, for chronic and acute effects, were executed on the occurrence and consumption data by a two-dimensional procedure, modelling variability and uncertainty. In the first step, the prioritisation method adopted allowed to reduce the number of substances by about 80%. These substances were in turn grouped based on their capacity to cause toxicological effects on common organ systems and, as second step, probabilistic combined exposure calculations were carried out for 16 target organ systems. This step allowed to identify the organ systems that need further assessment, reducing their initial number by about 70%. The organ systems would need to be prioritised as follows: reproductive and developmental toxicity, liver, kidney, male reproductive system, and haematopoietic system and haematology. The sources of uncertainty stemming from the modelling procedure and from methodological assumptions were discussed and their impact qualitatively assessed. Overall, it was concluded that the risk estimates for the different organ systems were more likely to be overestimated than underestimated.
为加速农药残留累积风险评估的实施,本报告描述了一个分两步进行的优先级分析,分别针对单一农药和目标器官系统,该分析能够识别:(i)预计对累积风险贡献较小的低优先级物质;(ii)未来累积风险评估中需要关注的高优先级器官系统。该分析涵盖了2019 - 2021年监测周期内对30个群体(涵盖3个年龄组和17个欧盟国家)调查的350种物质和36种植物源性初级商品。通过二维程序对慢性和急性影响的概率暴露进行计算,对发生和消费数据进行建模,以反映变异性和不确定性。第一步,所采用的优先级方法使物质数量减少了约80%。这些物质进而根据其对常见器官系统产生毒理学影响的能力进行分组,第二步,对16个目标器官系统进行概率性联合暴露计算。这一步骤能够识别出需要进一步评估的器官系统,使其初始数量减少了约70%。这些器官系统的优先级排序如下:生殖和发育毒性、肝脏、肾脏、男性生殖系统以及造血系统和血液学。讨论了建模程序和方法假设所产生的不确定性来源,并对其影响进行了定性评估。总体而言,得出的结论是,不同器官系统的风险估计更有可能被高估而非低估。