University of Helsinki, Finland.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2024 Dec;25(5):3696-3712. doi: 10.1177/15248380241257198. Epub 2024 Jun 13.
Hate crime victimization targeting the victim's religious identity poses a serious problem for individuals, communities, and societies. This systematic review describes countermeasures to such victimization, aiming for broad descriptive inclusion by canvassing personal adaptations, collective programs, and institutional-governmental policies. Targeting peer-reviewed articles published between 2002 and 2022, we found 44 articles describing measures related to religion-based victimization prevention. We classified the studied measures into 12 main types. The most salient personal adaptations included camouflage-type blending in to avoid victimization, using religion as a source of resilience, and changing routines to deflect risk. At the collective level, mobilizing community resilience, stereotype reduction, and place-based solutions were often researched. The relatively few institutional-level studies addressed measures to enhance the connection between victims and authorities by various means. The experimental studies heavily concentrated on experiments supporting the efficacy of changing people's perceptions as a means of prevention. The review concludes with a discussion about research and policy implications.
仇恨犯罪针对受害者的宗教身份,给个人、社区和社会都带来了严重的问题。本系统综述描述了针对这种犯罪的对策,旨在通过调查个人适应措施、集体方案和机构-政府政策,进行广泛的描述性纳入。本研究针对 2002 年至 2022 年间发表的同行评审文章,共发现 44 篇描述基于宗教的受害预防措施的文章。我们将研究措施分为 12 种主要类型。最突出的个人适应措施包括伪装式融合以避免受害、利用宗教作为韧性的来源,以及改变日常活动以规避风险。在集体层面,经常研究动员社区韧性、减少刻板印象和基于地点的解决方案。相对较少的机构层面的研究涉及通过各种手段加强受害者与当局联系的措施。实验研究主要集中在支持改变人们认知作为预防手段的有效性的实验上。综述最后讨论了研究和政策的影响。