Scheytt Carla, Pflüger Jessica
Institute of Sociology, Faculty of Social and Political Science, University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria.
Front Sociol. 2024 Sep 25;9:1458423. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2024.1458423. eCollection 2024.
Qualitative researchers often encounter ethical challenges during their research process. Due to the large number of papers in which researchers reflect on specific and various ethical challenges within their projects, it proves difficult to keep track of them. To capture these reflexive practices, we conducted a literature review of 72 papers in sociology. Our review shows who reflects on research ethics and when and where such reflections occur. We identify 11 ethical issues that sociologists reflect on. Some issues address the challenges of implementing established ethical principles, such as (1) informed consent, (2) voluntary participation, (3) avoiding harm, (4) anonymization, and (5) confidentiality. Others go beyond these principles and refer to (6) the relationship between researchers and participants, (7) power asymmetries, (8) protecting yourself as a researcher, (9) deviant actions, (10) covert research, and (11) leaving the field. Our findings help researchers gain an overview of ethical challenges, enhancing their reflexivity.
定性研究人员在其研究过程中经常遇到伦理挑战。由于大量论文中研究人员反思了其项目中具体的各种伦理挑战,因此很难对这些挑战进行跟踪。为了捕捉这些反思性实践,我们对72篇社会学论文进行了文献综述。我们的综述展示了谁反思研究伦理以及这些反思在何时何地发生。我们确定了社会学家反思的11个伦理问题。一些问题涉及实施既定伦理原则的挑战,如(1)知情同意、(2)自愿参与、(3)避免伤害、(4)匿名化和(5)保密。其他问题则超越了这些原则,涉及(6)研究人员与参与者之间的关系、(7)权力不对称、(8)保护自己作为研究人员、(9)越轨行为、(10)隐蔽研究和(11)离开研究领域。我们的研究结果有助于研究人员全面了解伦理挑战,增强他们的反思能力。