Marques Marta, Almeida Ana, Pereira Helder
Anesthesiology, Centro Hospitalar Universitário São João, Porto, PRT.
Surgery and Physiology, Faculty of Medicine, Universidade do Porto, Porto, PRT.
Cureus. 2024 Sep 14;16(9):e69405. doi: 10.7759/cureus.69405. eCollection 2024 Sep.
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and its autonomous learning processes (or machine learning) in medicine has revolutionized the global health landscape, providing faster and more accurate diagnoses, personalization of medical treatment, and efficient management of clinical information. However, this transformation is not without ethical challenges, which require a comprehensive and responsible approach. There are many fields where AI and medicine intersect, such as health education, patient-doctor interface, data management, diagnosis, intervention, and decision-making processes. For some of these fields, there are some guidelines to regulate them. AI has numerous applications in medicine, including medical imaging analysis, diagnosis, predictive analytics for patient outcomes, drug discovery and development, virtual health assistants, and remote patient monitoring. It is also used in robotic surgery, clinical decision support systems, AI-powered chatbots for triage, administrative workflow automation, and treatment recommendations. Despite numerous applications, there are several problems related to the use of AI identified in the literature in general and in medicine in particular. These problems are data privacy and security, bias and discrimination, lack of transparency (Black Box Problem), integration with existing systems, cost and accessibility disparities, risk of overconfidence in AI, technical limitations, accountability for AI errors, algorithmic interpretability, data standardization issues, unemployment, and challenges in clinical validation. Of the various problems already identified, the most worrying are data bias, the black box phenomenon, questions about data privacy, responsibility for decision-making, security issues for the human species, and technological unemployment. There are still several ethical problems associated with the use of AI autonomous learning algorithms, namely epistemic, normative, and comprehensive ethical problems (overarching). Addressing all these issues is crucial to ensure that the use of AI in healthcare is implemented ethically and responsibly, providing benefits to populations without compromising fundamental values. Ongoing dialogue between healthcare providers and the industry, the establishment of ethical guidelines and regulations, and considering not only current ethical dilemmas but also future perspectives are fundamental points for the application of AI to medical practice. The purpose of this review is to discuss the ethical issues of AI algorithms used mainly in data management, diagnosis, intervention, and decision-making processes.
人工智能(AI)及其自主学习过程(即机器学习)在医学领域的整合彻底改变了全球医疗格局,实现了更快、更准确的诊断,医疗个性化以及临床信息的高效管理。然而,这一变革并非没有伦理挑战,需要采取全面且负责任的方法。人工智能与医学交叉的领域众多,如健康教育、医患界面、数据管理、诊断、干预和决策过程等。对于其中一些领域,已有一些指导方针来进行规范。人工智能在医学中有众多应用,包括医学影像分析、诊断、患者预后预测分析、药物研发、虚拟健康助手以及远程患者监测等。它还用于机器人手术、临床决策支持系统、用于分诊的人工智能驱动聊天机器人、行政工作流程自动化以及治疗建议等。尽管应用广泛,但总体而言,尤其是在医学领域,文献中已确定了一些与人工智能使用相关的问题。这些问题包括数据隐私与安全、偏差与歧视、缺乏透明度(黑箱问题)、与现有系统的整合、成本与可及性差异、对人工智能过度自信的风险、技术限制、人工智能错误的问责、算法可解释性、数据标准化问题、失业以及临床验证方面的挑战。在已确定的各种问题中,最令人担忧的是数据偏差、黑箱现象、数据隐私问题、决策责任、人类安全问题以及技术性失业。使用人工智能自主学习算法仍存在一些伦理问题,即认知、规范和全面的伦理问题(总体性问题)。解决所有这些问题对于确保人工智能在医疗保健中的使用符合伦理且负责任至关重要,在不损害基本价值观的前提下为民众带来益处。医疗服务提供者与行业之间持续的对话、伦理指导方针和法规的制定,以及不仅考虑当前的伦理困境,还考虑未来的发展前景,是将人工智能应用于医疗实践的基本要点。本综述的目的是讨论主要用于数据管理、诊断、干预和决策过程的人工智能算法的伦理问题。