Aguiar-Leiva Virginia Patricia, Leiva-Fernández Francisca, Martín-Roselló Maria Luisa, Gomez-Garcia Rafael, Fernandez-Lopez Auxiliadora, Barnestein-Fonseca Pilar, Morales-Asencio Jose Miguel
Fundacion CUDECA, Málaga, Spain
Group CA15: Palliative Care, IBIMA Institute, Malaga, Spain.
BMJ Open. 2025 Jul 17;15(7):e102040. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2025-102040.
The needs of patients in palliative care (PC) are multiple and changing. Several tools assess them, but there is a lack of homogeneity among them. A specific diagnostic tool to assess complexity in PC (IDC-Pal: Instrumento Diagnóstico de la Complejidad en Cuidados Paliativos, in Spanish) was created in community and hospital settings with 36 items to diagnose PC complexity, but its application in primary care is difficult.
(1) To generate an adapted version to primary care of the IDC-Pal tool to identify and stratify PC complexity in the adult population. (2) To determine face, content, criterion and construct validity and reliability of the new instrument.
There are three phases of clinimetric cross-sectional observational validation study: : Review of the original tool structure suitability for its use in primary care setting by a committee (researchers and the original developer team). : Expert consensus phase by Delphi technique with physicians, nurses and social workers from primary care and PC. : Empirical validation of the resulting tool in primary care using a cross-sectional descriptive design involving physicians and case manager nurses from across Andalucia, who will recruit adult patients with PC needs from healthcare centres that accept to participate in the study. Reliability (Cronbach's alpha, McDonald's omega, interclass correlation coefficient) and construct validity (exploratory factor analysis) analysis will be carried out; convergent criterion validity will be assessed with the NEC-PAL (Necesidades Paliativas Questionnaire, in Spanish) instrument. Differences by gender, type of professional and place where it is administered will be explored. Interobserver reliability analyses will be carried out using intraclass correlation coefficient, Bland-Altman plots and concordance analysis. Phase 0-1 results were expected by 2025 and Phase 2 results by 2026. : CRISP checklist. This protocol was conducted without patient or public participation.
This study evaluates a novel, co-designed tool to diagnose PC complexity to inform practice recommendations for a more efficient allocation of resources that may be included in future clinical practice guidelines. The study has been approved by the Provincial Research Ethics Committee of Málaga as of July 2023 and will be conducted in accordance with the principles established in the Declaration of Helsinki, the Council of Europe Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, and the requirements established in Spanish legislation. The study conforms to the norms of good clinical practice. All participants in the Delphi study must express their agreement to participate in the survey by providing informed consent (IC) before beginning the questionnaire. For the development of Phase 2, the primary care professionals who agree to participate will sign a researcher commitment, and the patients included in the study will sign a written IC before the data collection. Dissemination of the results will inform future research on the appropriate diagnosis of PC complexity in the primary care setting, which is of paramount importance due to its gatekeeper position. Dissemination will be aimed at academics and healthcare professionals through publications, presentations and training workshops on the use of the diagnostic tool.
姑息治疗(PC)患者的需求是多方面且不断变化的。有多种工具可对这些需求进行评估,但它们之间缺乏同质性。在社区和医院环境中创建了一种用于评估PC复杂性的特定诊断工具(IDC-Pal:西班牙语为Instrumento Diagnóstico de la Complejidad en Cuidados Paliativos),该工具包含36个项目以诊断PC复杂性,但其在初级保健中的应用存在困难。
(1)生成IDC-Pal工具的初级保健适配版本,以识别和分层成年人群中的PC复杂性。(2)确定新工具的表面效度、内容效度、标准效度、结构效度和信度。
临床测量横断面观察性验证研究分为三个阶段:由一个委员会(研究人员和原始开发团队)审查原始工具结构是否适合在初级保健环境中使用。通过德尔菲技术与来自初级保健和PC领域的医生、护士和社会工作者进行专家共识阶段。使用横断面描述性设计对所得工具在初级保健中进行实证验证,该设计涉及来自安达卢西亚各地的医生和病例管理护士,他们将从接受参与研究的医疗中心招募有PC需求的成年患者。将进行信度(克朗巴哈α系数、麦克唐纳ω系数、组内相关系数)和结构效度(探索性因素分析)分析;将使用NEC-PAL(西班牙语为Necesidades Paliativas Questionnaire)工具评估收敛标准效度。将探索性别、专业类型和实施地点的差异。将使用组内相关系数、布兰德-奥特曼图和一致性分析进行观察者间信度分析。预计2025年得出0-1阶段结果,2026年得出2阶段结果。:CRISP清单。本方案未涉及患者或公众参与。
本研究评估一种新的、共同设计的工具,以诊断PC复杂性,为更有效分配资源的实践建议提供信息,这些建议可能会纳入未来的临床实践指南。该研究已于2023年7月获得马拉加省研究伦理委员会批准,并将按照《赫尔辛基宣言》、《欧洲人权与生物医学公约》确立的原则以及西班牙立法规定的要求进行。该研究符合良好临床实践规范。德尔菲研究的所有参与者必须在开始问卷前通过提供知情同意书(IC)表示同意参与调查。对于2阶段的开展,同意参与的初级保健专业人员将签署研究人员承诺书,研究中纳入的患者将在数据收集前签署书面IC。结果传播将为初级保健环境中PC复杂性的适当诊断的未来研究提供信息,鉴于其守门人地位,这至关重要。传播将通过关于诊断工具使用的出版物、演示文稿和培训研讨会面向学术界和医疗保健专业人员。