Mahony J B, Luinstra K E, Sellors J W, Pickard L, Chong S, Jang D, Chernesky M A
McMaster University Regional Virology, St. Joseph's Hospital, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
J Clin Microbiol. 1994 Oct;32(10):2490-3. doi: 10.1128/jcm.32.10.2490-2493.1994.
The role of confirmatory PCR assays for determining the performance of Chlamydia Amplicor PCR for endocervical specimens from women with a low prevalence of infection was evaluated. An endocervical swab was collected from 770 women and tested by culture or direct fluorescent antibody (DFA) staining. A second swab was tested by Chlamydia Amplicor PCR (Roche Molecular Systems, Branchburg, N.J.). Discordant results were resolved by three confirmatory PCRs: one targeting the plasmid by using different primers and two directed to the major outer membrane protein (MOMP) gene. Of the 30 swabs that were positive by culture or DFA (3.9%), 27 were positive by Amplicor PCR. An additional five swabs were positive by Amplicor PCR but negative by culture or DFA. Both plasmid and MOMP confirmatory PCRs identified the five culture-DFA negatives and the three Amplicor negatives as true positives. The three specimens originally classified as negative by Amplicor PCR were positive on repeat Amplicor testing. After resolution of the discordant results by confirmatory PCR testing, the sensitivity of the initial Amplicor PCR was 91.4% (32 of 35 specimens), changing to 100% after storage and repeat testing. The specificity of Amplicor PCR was 100% (735 of 735 specimens). Our results demonstrated that plasmid and MOMP confirmatory PCRs worked equally well in resolving false-positive and false-negative Amplicor PCR results. Some specimens may contain inhibitors of Amplicor PCR which may disappear with time.
对确认性聚合酶链反应(PCR)检测在确定衣原体扩增PCR对感染率较低的女性宫颈标本检测性能方面的作用进行了评估。从770名女性中采集宫颈拭子,通过培养或直接荧光抗体(DFA)染色进行检测。第二个拭子通过衣原体扩增PCR(罗氏分子系统公司,新泽西州布兰奇堡)进行检测。不一致的结果通过三种确认性PCR来解决:一种使用不同引物靶向质粒,另外两种针对主要外膜蛋白(MOMP)基因。在通过培养或DFA检测为阳性的30个拭子中(3.9%),27个通过扩增PCR检测为阳性。另外有5个拭子通过扩增PCR检测为阳性,但通过培养或DFA检测为阴性。质粒和MOMP确认性PCR均将5个培养-DFA检测为阴性的拭子以及3个扩增检测为阴性的拭子鉴定为真正阳性。最初被扩增PCR分类为阴性的3个标本在重复扩增检测时为阳性。通过确认性PCR检测解决不一致结果后,初始扩增PCR的敏感性为91.4%(35个标本中的32个),储存和重复检测后变为100%。扩增PCR的特异性为100%(735个标本中的735个)。我们的结果表明,质粒和MOMP确认性PCR在解决扩增PCR的假阳性和假阴性结果方面效果相同。一些标本可能含有扩增PCR的抑制剂,这些抑制剂可能会随时间消失。