Strauss R R, Holderbach J, Friedman H
J Clin Microbiol. 1978 May;7(5):419-22. doi: 10.1128/jcm.7.5.419-422.1978.
A radiometric procedure was compared with the conventional cystine tryptic agar (CTA) sugar fermentation method for identification of Neisseria species. Four different ATCC cultures of Neisseria were identified by both procedures with identical results. The only difference noted was that the radiometric procedure required 3 h for completion, whereas the conventional CTA sugar method required overnight incubation. The radiometric procedure was also compared with the fluorescent antibody (FA) and CTA methods for identification of Neisseria gonorrhoeae. The organisms examined were gram-negative, oxidase-positive diplococci isolated from 49 clinical specimens sent to the laboratory for bacteriological analysis. Results obtained by both CTA and FA procedures were comparable. However, the radioisotope method appeared to be superior to the other two methods in that only one isolate identified as positive by both the CTA and FA methods was not identified radiometrically, whereas four isolates positive by the radiometric method were not identified by the other two procedures. Thus, a total of seven more positive identifications were made radiometrically than by either of the two other methods. All positive identifications were confirmed by a reference laboratory. These results indicate that the radiometric procedure is more rapid and reliable as compared with both the CTA and direct FA methods and, thus, may serve as a valuable addition to the methodology available for diagnostic microbiology.
将一种放射性测量方法与传统的胱氨酸胰蛋白酶琼脂(CTA)糖发酵法进行比较,以鉴定奈瑟菌属菌种。通过这两种方法对4种不同的奈瑟菌ATCC培养物进行鉴定,结果相同。唯一的区别是,放射性测量方法需要3小时完成,而传统的CTA糖方法需要过夜培养。还将放射性测量方法与荧光抗体(FA)法和CTA法进行比较,以鉴定淋病奈瑟菌。所检测的菌株为从送至实验室进行细菌学分析的49份临床标本中分离出的革兰氏阴性、氧化酶阳性双球菌。CTA法和FA法获得的结果具有可比性。然而,放射性同位素方法似乎优于其他两种方法,因为在CTA法和FA法均鉴定为阳性的分离株中,只有1株未通过放射性测量法鉴定,而在放射性测量法鉴定为阳性的分离株中,有4株未被其他两种方法鉴定。因此,通过放射性测量法进行的阳性鉴定比其他两种方法中的任何一种都多7例。所有阳性鉴定均由参考实验室确认。这些结果表明,与CTA法和直接FA法相比,放射性测量方法更快且更可靠,因此,可作为诊断微生物学现有方法的一个有价值的补充。