Smith D L, Petruzzello S J
Human Performance Laboratory, Skidmore College, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866, USA.
Ergonomics. 1998 Aug;41(8):1141-54. doi: 10.1080/001401398186441.
The purpose of this study was to examine selected physiological and psychological responses to strenuous live-fire drills in different configurations of protective firefighting gear. Career firefighters (n = 10) performed three sets of firefighting drills in a training structure that contained live fires in two different configurations of firefighting gear. On separate days subjects wore: (a) the NFPA 1500 (1987) standard configuration, and (b) a hip-boot configuration of the firefighting gear. Physiological and psychological measurements were recorded pre-activity and at the end of each trial. Repeated measures ANOVA revealed a strong trend for performance time to be greater in the 1500 gear than in the hip-boot gear. There was a significant Time x Gear interaction for tympanic membrane temperature, with temperature being greater in the 1500 gear. Perceptions of effort and thermal sensations were also greater in the 1500 gear than in the hip-boot configuration of the gear. There was little difference in mean performance on cognitive function measures between the two gear configurations, but there was greater variability in performance in the 1500 gear. These data suggest that performing strenuous firefighting drills in the current NFPA 1500 standard configuration results in longer performance time, greater thermal strain, and greater perception of effort and thermal sensation.
本研究的目的是检验在不同配置的消防防护装备下,对剧烈实火演练的特定生理和心理反应。职业消防员(n = 10)在一个包含实火的训练结构中进行了三组消防演练,演练时穿着两种不同配置的消防装备。在不同的日子里,受试者分别穿着:(a)NFPA 1500(1987)标准配置的装备,以及(b)一种高腰靴配置的消防装备。在活动前和每次试验结束时记录生理和心理测量数据。重复测量方差分析显示,使用1500装备时的表现时间比使用高腰靴装备时更长,这是一个明显的趋势。鼓膜温度存在显著的时间×装备交互作用,1500装备的温度更高。在1500装备中,对努力程度的感知和热感觉也比高腰靴配置的装备更强。两种装备配置在认知功能测量方面的平均表现差异不大,但1500装备的表现变异性更大。这些数据表明,按照当前NFPA 1500标准配置进行剧烈的消防演练会导致更长的表现时间、更大的热应激,以及对努力程度和热感觉的更强感知。