Chace D H, Sherwin J E, Hillman S L, Lorey F, Cunningham G C
1 Neo Gen Screening, 110 Roessler Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15220, USA.
Clin Chem. 1998 Dec;44(12):2405-9.
We compared the screening interpretation of fluorometric analytical results for phenylketonuria (PKU) with tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) in filter paper blood spots collected from newborns <24 h of age. In MS/MS, both Phe and Tyr are quantified. Two hundred and eight blood spots collected from infants <24 h of age were retrieved from storage from the California newborn screening program. These samples had been categorized on the basis of fluorometric analysis as initial negative, initial positive for hyperphenylalaninemia with negative determination on recall, or initial positive for hyperphenylalaninemia and confirmed on follow up as PKU or variant hyperphenylalaninemia. The retrieved samples were analyzed in a blinded fashion using MS/MS. Correlation analysis of fluorometry vs MS/MS for Phe concentration was high, with a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.817. When 180 micromol/L was used as the cutoff Phe concentration for MS/MS and 258 micromol/L was used as the cutoff for fluorometry, all infants with confirmed classical PKU and variant hyperphenylalaninemia were detected. MS/MS analysis reduced the number of false-positive results from 91 to 3. Simultaneous quantification of Phe and Tyr by MS/MS with the use of a cutoff Phe/Tyr molar ratio of 2.5 further reduced the number of false positives to 1. Samples from affected infants showed a discernible trend of increasing Phe concentration and Phe/Tyr molar ratio with age of collection. These results demonstrate the utility of MS/MS in the routine PKU screening of early-discharge newborns. MS/MS reduces the false-positive rate of fluorometric screening almost 100-fold because of the improved accuracy and precision of Phe measurement and simultaneous confirmation with the Phe/Tyr molar ratio. In addition to the detection of PKU, MS/MS can also detect other aminoacidopathies and disorders of fatty acid and organic acid metabolism with lower false-positive rates than other methods currently used in newborn screening programs.
我们比较了荧光分析法和串联质谱法(MS/MS)对出生不足24小时新生儿滤纸血斑中苯丙酮尿症(PKU)筛查结果的解读。在MS/MS中,苯丙氨酸(Phe)和酪氨酸(Tyr)均被定量检测。从加利福尼亚州新生儿筛查项目的储存样本中找回了208份出生不足24小时婴儿的血斑样本。这些样本在荧光分析的基础上被分类为初始阴性、高苯丙氨酸血症初始阳性但召回检测为阴性,或高苯丙氨酸血症初始阳性且后续确诊为PKU或变异型高苯丙氨酸血症。对找回的样本采用MS/MS进行盲法分析。Phe浓度的荧光法与MS/MS的相关性分析很高,Pearson相关系数为0.817。当将180 μmol/L用作MS/MS的Phe浓度临界值,258 μmol/L用作荧光法的临界值时,所有确诊为经典型PKU和变异型高苯丙氨酸血症的婴儿均被检测出来。MS/MS分析将假阳性结果数量从91例减少至3例。通过MS/MS同时定量Phe和Tyr,并使用2.5的Phe/Tyr摩尔比临界值,可进一步将假阳性数量减少至1例。患病婴儿的样本显示,随着采集时年龄的增加,Phe浓度和Phe/Tyr摩尔比呈明显上升趋势。这些结果证明了MS/MS在早期出院新生儿PKU常规筛查中的实用性。由于Phe测量的准确性和精密度提高,并通过Phe/Tyr摩尔比进行同步确认,MS/MS将荧光筛查的假阳性率降低了近100倍。除了检测PKU外,MS/MS还能检测其他氨基酸代谢病以及脂肪酸和有机酸代谢紊乱,其假阳性率低于目前新生儿筛查项目中使用的其他方法。