Vilhjalmsson Runar, Kristjansdottir Gudrun
Faculty of Nursing, University of Iceland, Eiriksgotu 34, Eirbergi, IS-101 Reykjavik, Iceland.
Soc Sci Med. 2003 Jan;56(2):363-74. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(02)00042-4.
Previous studies have generally had limited success in accounting for gender differences in leisure time physical activity. Based on a representative national survey of 3270 Icelandic 6th, 8th and 10th grade students, the study found that girls' lower enrollment in organized sport clubs fully accounts for gender differences in frequency of overall physical activity, and largely accounts for gender differences in frequency of strenuous activity, and weekly hours of overall and strenuous activity (enrollment hypothesis). Furthermore, girls' higher sport club withdrawal rate accounted for a small but significant part of the gender difference in weekly hours of overall activity and frequency of strenuous activity (withdrawal hypothesis). No evidence was found to suggest that different activity levels of boys and girls enrolled in the clubs affected gender differences in levels of overall or strenuous physical activity (activity differential hypothesis). Other independent variables, i.e., perceived importance of sport achievement, sport and exercise related instruction, physical education experiences, and social modeling, did not significantly affect observed gender differences beyond the sport club variables. The meaning of the results, and their implications for gender disparities, health promotion, and future research are discussed.
以往的研究在解释休闲时间体育活动中的性别差异方面,总体成效有限。基于一项对3270名冰岛6年级、8年级和10年级学生的全国代表性调查,该研究发现,女孩参加有组织体育俱乐部的人数较少,这完全解释了总体体育活动频率方面的性别差异,并且在很大程度上解释了剧烈活动频率以及总体和剧烈活动的每周时长方面的性别差异(参与假设)。此外,女孩较高的体育俱乐部退出率在总体活动每周时长和剧烈活动频率的性别差异中占了一小部分但显著的比例(退出假设)。没有证据表明,参加俱乐部的男孩和女孩的不同活动水平会影响总体或剧烈体育活动水平方面的性别差异(活动差异假设)。其他自变量,即对体育成就的感知重要性、与体育和锻炼相关的指导、体育教育经历以及社会榜样作用,在体育俱乐部变量之外,并未对观察到的性别差异产生显著影响。本文讨论了研究结果的意义及其对性别差异、健康促进和未来研究的启示。