Camilleri M, Zinsmeister A R, Greydanus M P, Brown M L, Proano M
Department of Health Sciences Research (Biostatistics), Mayo Clinic and Foundation, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
Dig Dis Sci. 1991 May;36(5):609-15. doi: 10.1007/BF01297027.
Our aim is to develop a less costly but accurate test of stomach emptying and small bowel transit by utilizing selected scintigraphic observations 1-6 hr after ingestion of a radiolabeled solid meal. These selected data were compared with more detailed analyses that require multiple scans and labor-intensive technical support. A logistic discriminant analysis was used to estimate the sensitivity and specificity of selected summaries of scintigraphic transit measurements. We studied 14 patients with motility disorders (eight neuropathic and six myopathic, confirmed by standard gastrointestinal manometry) and 37 healthy subjects. The patient group had abnormal gastric emptying (GE) and small bowel transit time (SBTT). The proportion of radiolabel retained in the stomach from 2 to 4 hr (GE 2 hr, GE 3 hr, GE 4 hr), as well as the proportion filling the colon at 4 and 6 hr (CF 4 hr, CF 6 hr) were individually able to differentiate health from disease (P less than 0.05 for each). From the logistic discriminant model, an estimated sensitivity of 93% resulted in similar specificities for detailed and selected transit parameters for gastric emptying (range: 62-70%). Similarly, combining selected observations, such as GE 4 hr with CF 6 hr, had a specificity of 76%, which was similar to the specificity of combinations of more detailed analyses. Based on the present studies and future confirmation in a larger number of patients, including those with less severe motility disorders, the 2-, 4-, and 6-hr scans with quantitation of proportions of counts in stomach and colon should provide a useful, relatively inexpensive strategy to identify and monitor motility disorders in clinical and epidemiologic studies.
我们的目标是通过利用摄入放射性标记固体餐1 - 6小时后的特定闪烁扫描观察结果,开发一种成本较低但准确的胃排空和小肠转运测试方法。将这些选定的数据与需要多次扫描和劳动密集型技术支持的更详细分析进行比较。使用逻辑判别分析来估计闪烁扫描转运测量选定总结的敏感性和特异性。我们研究了14例运动障碍患者(8例神经病变型和6例肌病型,经标准胃肠测压法确诊)和37名健康受试者。患者组的胃排空(GE)和小肠转运时间(SBTT)异常。2至4小时胃内保留的放射性标记比例(GE 2小时、GE 3小时、GE 4小时),以及4和6小时结肠内充盈的比例(CF 4小时、CF 6小时)各自能够区分健康与疾病(每项P值均小于0.05)。从逻辑判别模型来看,估计敏感性为93%,胃排空详细和选定转运参数的特异性相似(范围:62 - 70%)。同样,将选定的观察结果(如GE 4小时与CF 6小时)相结合,特异性为76%,这与更详细分析组合的特异性相似。基于目前的研究以及未来在更多患者(包括运动障碍较轻的患者)中的验证,对胃和结肠内计数比例进行定量的2小时、4小时和6小时扫描,应能为临床和流行病学研究中识别和监测运动障碍提供一种有用且相对廉价的策略。