Zazove Philip, Meador Helen E, Reed Barbara D, Sen Ananda, Gorenflo Daniel W
Department of Family Medicine, University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor, MI 48104-1213, USA.
J Cancer Educ. 2012 Jun;27(2):327-37. doi: 10.1007/s13187-011-0292-1.
Deaf persons have a poorer understanding of cancer prevention, which is felt to be partly due to communication barriers. One hundred ninety-seven d/Deaf persons completed a survey and video on cancer prevention. Half viewed a spoken English program designed for hearing persons (control group); the other half viewed an amended program that had American Sign Language, captions, and printed English options added (experimental group). Knowledge was measured before and after the video, including 1 and 6 months later. Respondents were primarily Caucasian, had low incomes, lost hearing at young ages, and had d/Deaf spouses. Although overall knowledge improved after viewing the video, the presence of culture-specific communications (American Sign Language, captions) did not improve scores compared to the control group, either immediately after the intervention or over time. Moreover, percentage correct on all pretest, and almost all post-test, questions was <50% for both experimental and control groups. For all subjects, regardless of which group they were in, a hearing spouse (p < 0.001) and more healthcare information sources (p = 0.001) improved knowledge, while African-Americans showed a trend to lesser improvement (p = 0.06). Using culture-specific language did not improve cancer prevention knowledge in this d/Deaf population, and overall knowledge remained low. More study is needed to determine the best way to increase cancer prevention knowledge in this population.
聋人对癌症预防的理解较差,这被认为部分归因于沟通障碍。197名聋人完成了一项关于癌症预防的调查及视频观看。一半人观看了为听力正常者设计的英语口语节目(对照组);另一半人观看了添加了美国手语、字幕和印刷英语选项的修改版节目(实验组)。在观看视频前及观看后,包括1个月和6个月后,对知识进行了测量。受访者主要为白人,收入较低,在年轻时失聪,且配偶为聋人。尽管观看视频后总体知识有所提高,但与对照组相比,无论是在干预后立即还是随着时间推移,特定文化的沟通方式(美国手语、字幕)并没有提高得分。此外,实验组和对照组在所有预测试题以及几乎所有后测试题上的正确百分比均<50%。对于所有受试者,无论他们属于哪个组,有听力的配偶(p < 0.001)和更多的医疗保健信息来源(p = 0.001)可提高知识水平,而非洲裔美国人的知识水平提高趋势较小(p = 0.06)。使用特定文化的语言并没有提高这一聋人群体的癌症预防知识,且总体知识水平仍然较低。需要更多研究来确定增加该群体癌症预防知识的最佳方法。