Iacono Teresa, Bigby Christine, Unsworth Carolyn, Douglas Jacinta, Fitzpatrick Petya
La Trobe Rural Health School, La Trobe University, Bendigo, Bendigo 3552, Victoria, Australia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2014 Oct 25;14:505. doi: 10.1186/s12913-014-0505-5.
People with intellectual disability are at risk of poor hospital experiences and outcomes. The aims were to conduct a content and quality review of research into the acute hospital experiences of both people with intellectual disabilities and their carers, and to identify research gaps.
A systematic search was conducted of primary research between 2009 and 2013 that addressed the experiences of the target group in general acute care hospitals. Quality appraisal tools yielded scores for quantitative and qualitative studies, and overarching themes across studies were sought.
Sixteen studies met inclusion criteria. Quality scores were 6/8 for a survey, and 2/11-9/11 (mean =5.25) for qualitative studies/components. Content analysis revealed seven over-arching themes covering individuals' fear of hospital encounters, carer responsibilities, and problems with delivery of care in hospitals including staff knowledge, skills and attitudes.
Our review of eligible papers revealed that despite 20 years of research and government initiatives, people with intellectual disability continue to have poor hospital experiences. The need for research to identify and investigate care at specific points of encounter across a hospital journey (such as admission, diagnostic testing, placement on a ward, and discharge) as well as to include people with a diversity of disabilities is discussed in terms of potential to influence policy and practice across health and disability sectors.
智障人士面临医院体验不佳和预后不良的风险。目的是对有关智障人士及其照顾者在急症医院体验的研究进行内容和质量审查,并找出研究空白。
对2009年至2013年间针对普通急症医院中目标群体体验的原始研究进行系统检索。质量评估工具得出了定量和定性研究的分数,并找出了各项研究的总体主题。
16项研究符合纳入标准。一项调查的质量得分为6/8,定性研究/部分的得分为2/11 - 9/11(平均 = 5.25)。内容分析揭示了七个总体主题,涵盖个人对医院就医的恐惧、照顾者的责任以及医院护理提供方面的问题,包括工作人员的知识、技能和态度。
我们对符合条件的论文进行的审查表明,尽管经过了20年的研究和政府举措,智障人士的医院体验仍然不佳。从影响卫生和残疾部门政策及实践的潜力方面讨论了开展研究以确定和调查医院就医过程中特定接触点(如入院、诊断测试、病房安置和出院)的护理情况以及纳入各类残疾人士的必要性。