Cervantes Lilia, Jones Jacqueline, Linas Stuart, Fischer Stacy
Divisions of Hospital Medicine and.
Department of Medicine and.
Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2017 May 8;12(5):788-798. doi: 10.2215/CJN.10260916. Epub 2017 Apr 12.
Compared with non-Latino whites with advanced illness, Latinos are less likely to have an advance directive or to die with hospice services. To improve palliative care disparities, international ESRD guidelines call for increased research on culturally responsive communication of advance care planning (ACP). The objective of our study was to explore the preferences of Latino patients receiving dialysis regarding symptom management and ACP.
DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS: Qualitative study design using semistructured face-to-face interviews of 20 Latinos on hemodialysis between February and July of 2015. Data were analyzed using thematic analysis.
Four themes were identified: Avoiding harms of medication (fear of addiction and damage to bodies, effective distractions, reliance on traditional remedies, fatalism: the sense that one's illness is deserved punishment); barriers and facilitators to ACP: faith, family, and home (family group decision-making, family reluctance to have ACP conversations, flexible decision-making conversations at home with family, ACP conversations incorporating trust and linguistic congruency, family-first and faith-driven decisions); enhancing wellbeing day-to-day (supportive relationships, improved understanding of illness leads to adherence, recognizing new self-value, maintaining a positive outlook); and distressing aspects of living with their illness (dietary restriction is culturally isolating and challenging for families, logistic challenges and socioeconomic disadvantage compounded by health literacy and language barriers, required rapid adjustments to chronic illness, demanding dialysis schedule).
Latinos described unique cultural preferences such as avoidance of medications for symptom alleviation and a preference to have family group decision-making and ACP conversations at home. Understanding and integrating cultural values and preferences into palliative care offers the potential to improve disparities and achieve quality patient-centered care for Latinos with advanced illness.
与患有晚期疾病的非拉丁裔白人相比,拉丁裔拥有预先指示或接受临终关怀服务离世的可能性较小。为改善姑息治疗的差异,国际终末期肾病指南呼吁加强对具有文化适应性的预先护理计划(ACP)沟通的研究。我们研究的目的是探讨接受透析的拉丁裔患者在症状管理和ACP方面的偏好。
设计、背景、参与者及测量方法:采用定性研究设计,于2015年2月至7月对20名接受血液透析的拉丁裔患者进行半结构化面对面访谈。使用主题分析法对数据进行分析。
确定了四个主题:避免药物危害(害怕成瘾和身体损伤、有效的分散注意力方式、依赖传统疗法、宿命论:认为患病是应得的惩罚);ACP的障碍与促进因素:信仰、家庭和家庭环境(家庭集体决策、家人不愿进行ACP对话、在家中与家人进行灵活的决策对话、包含信任和语言一致性的ACP对话、以家庭为先和受信仰驱动的决策);日常增进幸福感(支持性的人际关系、对疾病的更好理解导致依从性提高、认识到新的自我价值、保持积极的心态);以及患病生活中的困扰方面(饮食限制在文化上使家庭孤立并具有挑战性、后勤挑战和社会经济劣势因健康素养和语言障碍而加剧、需要对慢性病迅速进行调整、苛刻的透析时间表)。
拉丁裔描述了独特的文化偏好,例如避免使用药物缓解症状,以及倾向于进行家庭集体决策和在家中进行ACP对话。理解并将文化价值观和偏好融入姑息治疗有可能改善差异,并为患有晚期疾病的拉丁裔患者提供以患者为中心的优质护理。