Bolotin Shelly, Lim Gillian, Dang Vica, Crowcroft Natasha, Gubbay Jonathan, Mazzulli Tony, Schabas Richard
Public Health Ontario, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2017 Aug 29;12(8):e0181172. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0181172. eCollection 2017.
In Canada, measles was eliminated in 1998 and rubella in 2000. Effective measles and rubella surveillance is vital in elimination settings, hinging on reliable laboratory methods. However, low-prevalence settings affect the predictive value of laboratory tests. We conducted an analysis to determine the performance of measles and rubella IgM testing in a jurisdiction where both infections are eliminated. 21,299 test results were extracted from the Public Health Ontario Laboratories database and 1,239 reports were extracted from the Ontario Integrated Public Health Information System (iPHIS) from 2008 and 2010 for measles and rubella, respectively, to 2014. Deterministic linkage resulted in 658 linked measles records (2009-2014) and 189 linked rubella records (2010-2014). Sixty-six iPHIS measles entries were classified as confirmed cases, of which 53 linked to laboratory data. Five iPHIS rubella entries were classified as confirmed, all linked to IgM results. The positive predictive value was 17.4% for measles and 3.6% for rubella. Sensitivity was 79.2% for measles and 100.0% for rubella. Specificity was 65.7% for measles and 25.8% for rubella. Our study confirms that a positive IgM alone does not confirm a measles case in elimination settings. This has important implications for countries that are working towards measles and rubella elimination.
在加拿大,麻疹于1998年被消灭,风疹于2000年被消灭。在已实现消灭的环境中,有效的麻疹和风疹监测至关重要,这取决于可靠的实验室方法。然而,低流行环境会影响实验室检测的预测价值。我们进行了一项分析,以确定在两种感染均已被消灭的辖区内麻疹和风疹IgM检测的性能。从安大略省公共卫生实验室数据库中提取了21299份检测结果,并分别从安大略省综合公共卫生信息系统(iPHIS)中提取了2008年至2010年以及2014年的1239份麻疹和风疹报告。确定性关联产生了658条关联的麻疹记录(2009 - 2014年)和189条关联的风疹记录(2010 - 2014年)。iPHIS中有66条麻疹记录被分类为确诊病例,其中53条与实验室数据相关联。iPHIS中有5条风疹记录被分类为确诊,均与IgM结果相关联。麻疹的阳性预测值为17.4%,风疹为3.6%。麻疹的敏感性为79.2%,风疹为100.0%。麻疹的特异性为65.7%,风疹为25.8%。我们的研究证实,在已实现消灭的环境中,仅IgM阳性并不能确诊麻疹病例。这对正在努力实现麻疹和风疹消灭的国家具有重要意义。