Armstead Theresa L, Wilkins Natalie, Doreson Amanda
Division of Violence Prevention, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (Dr Armstead and Ms Doreson); and Division of Analysis, Research, and Practice Integration, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (Dr Wilkins).
J Public Health Manag Pract. 2018 Jan/Feb;24 Suppl 1 Suppl, Injury and Violence Prevention(Suppl 1 INJURY AND VIOLENCE PREVENTION):S42-S50. doi: 10.1097/PHH.0000000000000681.
Programs geared toward preventing violence before it occurs at the community and societal levels of the social ecology are particularly challenging to evaluate. These programs are often focused on impacting the antecedents (or risk and protective factors) to violence, making it difficult to determine program success when solely relying on measures of violence reduction. The goal of this literature review is to identify indicators to measure risk and protective factors for violence that are accessible and measured at the community level. Indicators of community- and societal-level risk and protective factors from 116 articles are identified. These indicators strengthen violence prevention researchers' and practitioners' ability to detect proximal effects of violence prevention programs, practices, and policies, and provide timely feedback on the impact of their work. Thus, opportunities exist for violence prevention researchers to further study the associations between various indicators and different violent outcomes and to inform practitioner, evaluator, and funder developed logic models that include indicators of relevant risk and protective factors for crosscutting violence prevention measures and outcomes.
针对在社会生态的社区和社会层面预防暴力行为发生的项目,评估起来特别具有挑战性。这些项目通常侧重于影响暴力行为的前因(或风险因素和保护因素),这使得仅依靠减少暴力行为的衡量标准来确定项目是否成功变得困难。本文献综述的目的是确定可在社区层面获取并衡量的、用于衡量暴力行为风险因素和保护因素的指标。从116篇文章中确定了社区和社会层面风险因素和保护因素的指标。这些指标增强了预防暴力行为研究人员和从业者检测预防暴力行为项目、实践和政策的近端影响的能力,并为他们的工作影响提供及时反馈。因此,预防暴力行为研究人员有机会进一步研究各种指标与不同暴力结果之间的关联,并为从业者、评估人员和资助者制定的逻辑模型提供信息,这些逻辑模型包括针对贯穿各领域的预防暴力行为措施和结果的相关风险因素和保护因素的指标。