Department of Psychology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3EB, United Kingdom;
Behavioural and Clinical Neuroscience Institute, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3EB, United Kingdom.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2018 May 8;115(19):E4532-E4540. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1708960115. Epub 2018 Apr 19.
Nationalistic identities often play an influential role in citizens' voting behavior and political engagement. Nationalistic ideologies tend to have firm categories and rules for what belongs to and represents the national culture. In a sample of 332 UK citizens, we tested whether strict categorization of stimuli and rules in objective cognitive tasks would be evident in strongly nationalistic individuals. Using voting behavior and attitudes from the United Kingdom's 2016 EU referendum, we found that a flexible representation of national identity and culture was linked to cognitive flexibility in the ideologically neutral Wisconsin Card Sorting Test and Remote Associates Test, and to self-reported flexibility under uncertainty. Path analysis revealed that subjective and objective cognitive inflexibility predicted heightened authoritarianism, nationalism, conservatism, and system justification, and these in turn were predictive of support for Brexit and opposition to immigration, the European Union, and free movement of labor. This model accounted for 47.6% of the variance in support for Brexit. Path analysis models were also predictive of participants' sense of personal attachment to the United Kingdom, signifying that individual differences in cognitive flexibility may contribute toward ideological thinking styles that shape both nationalistic attitudes and personal sense of nationalistic identity. These findings further suggest that emotionally neutral "cold" cognitive information processing-and not just "hot" emotional cognition-may play a key role in ideological behavior and identity.
民族主义身份在公民的投票行为和政治参与中常常起着重要的作用。民族主义意识形态倾向于对属于和代表民族文化的事物进行严格的分类和规定。在一项对 332 名英国公民的抽样调查中,我们测试了在强烈的民族主义者中,客观认知任务中的严格分类和规则是否明显。通过对英国 2016 年欧盟公投的投票行为和态度进行研究,我们发现,对民族身份和文化的灵活表现与在意识形态中立的威斯康星卡片分类测试和远程联想测试中的认知灵活性有关,与在不确定情况下的自我报告灵活性有关。路径分析显示,主观和客观认知灵活性的降低预测了威权主义、民族主义、保守主义和制度正当化程度的增加,而这些因素反过来又预示着支持英国脱欧、反对移民、欧盟和劳动力自由流动。该模型解释了 47.6%的英国脱欧支持率的差异。路径分析模型也可以预测参与者对英国的个人依恋感,这表明认知灵活性的个体差异可能有助于形成塑造民族主义态度和个人民族主义身份感的意识形态思维方式。这些发现进一步表明,情感中立的“冷”认知信息处理——而不仅仅是“热”情感认知——可能在意识形态行为和身份认同中起着关键作用。