Charlton J R, Velez R
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1986 Feb 1;292(6516):295-301. doi: 10.1136/bmj.292.6516.295.
A series of outcome indicators was proposed for assessing the curative aspects of health care using several diseases for which evidence suggested that death was largely avoidable provided that appropriate medical treatment could be given in time. International data were examined for those causes for which data were readily available. Time trends in mortality were compared for each of these conditions for six countries that had experienced appreciable growth in health services during 1950-80. Mortality from the heterogeneous "avoidable" causes had declined faster than mortality from all other causes in each of the six countries. Despite problems of diagnosis, reporting, and classification of diseases that may have existed among countries, making international comparisons of absolute mortality difficult, the trends of declining mortality were similar, lending credibility to the use of these causes of mortality as indices of health care within countries. Changes within countries may also have been attributable to changes in social, environmental, genetic, and diagnostic factors, which were not examined. Nevertheless, the consistency in mortality trends for this group of "amenable" diseases suggested that improvements in medical care were a factor in their rapid decline.
有人提出了一系列结果指标,用于评估医疗保健的治疗效果,这些指标涉及几种疾病,有证据表明,只要能及时给予适当的医疗治疗,死亡在很大程度上是可以避免的。对有现成数据的那些病因进行了国际数据研究。对1950年至1980年间卫生服务有显著增长的六个国家,比较了每种疾病的死亡率时间趋势。在这六个国家中,由各种 “可避免” 病因导致的死亡率下降速度比所有其他病因导致的死亡率下降速度都要快。尽管各国之间可能存在疾病诊断、报告和分类方面的问题,使得绝对死亡率的国际比较变得困难,但死亡率下降趋势是相似的,这使得将这些死亡病因用作各国医疗保健指标具有可信度。各国国内的变化也可能归因于社会、环境、遗传和诊断因素的变化,但本文未对此进行研究。然而,这组 “可治疗” 疾病死亡率趋势的一致性表明,医疗保健的改善是其快速下降的一个因素。