Multi-Institutional Assessment and Crowdsourcing Evaluation of Deep Learning for Automated Classification of Breast Density.

OBJECTIVE

We developed deep learning algorithms to automatically assess BI-RADS breast density.

METHODS

Using a large multi-institution patient cohort of 108,230 digital screening mammograms from the Digital Mammographic Imaging Screening Trial, we investigated the effect of data, model, and training parameters on overall model performance and provided crowdsourcing evaluation from the attendees of the ACR 2019 Annual Meeting.

RESULTS

Our best-performing algorithm achieved good agreement with radiologists who were qualified interpreters of mammograms, with a four-class κ of 0.667. When training was performed with randomly sampled images from the data set versus sampling equal number of images from each density category, the model predictions were biased away from the low-prevalence categories such as extremely dense breasts. The net result was an increase in sensitivity and a decrease in specificity for predicting dense breasts for equal class compared with random sampling. We also found that the performance of the model degrades when we evaluate on digital mammography data formats that differ from the one that we trained on, emphasizing the importance of multi-institutional training sets. Lastly, we showed that crowdsourced annotations, including those from attendees who routinely read mammograms, had higher agreement with our algorithm than with the original interpreting radiologists.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated the possible parameters that can influence the performance of the model and how crowdsourcing can be used for evaluation. This study was performed in tandem with the development of the ACR AI-LAB, a platform for democratizing artificial intelligence.