Borra Davide, Andalò Alice, Paci Michelangelo, Fabbri Claudio, Corsi Cristiana
Department of Electrical, Electronic and Information Engineering "Guglielmo Marconi" (DEI), University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
BioMediTech, Faculty of Medicine and Health Technology, Tampere University, FI-33520 Tampere, Finland.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2020 Oct;10(10):1894-1907. doi: 10.21037/qims-20-168.
Several studies suggest that the evaluation of left atrial (LA) fibrosis is a relevant information for the assessment of the appropriate strategy in catheter ablation in atrial fibrillation (AF). Late gadolinium enhanced (LGE) cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a non-invasive technique, which might be employed for the non-invasive quantification of LA myocardial fibrotic tissue in patients with AF. Nowadays, the analysis of LGE MRI relies on manual tracing of LA boundaries and this procedure is time-consuming and prone to high inter-observer variability given the different degrees of observers' experience, LA wall thickness and data resolution. Therefore, an automated segmentation approach of the atrial cavity for the quantification of scar tissue would be highly desirable.
This study focuses on the design of a fully automated LGE MRI segmentation pipeline which includes a convolutional neural network (CNN) based on the successful architecture U-Net. The CNN was trained, validated and tested end-to-end with the data available from the Statistical Atlases and Computational Modelling of the Heart 2018 Atrial Segmentation Challenge (100 cardiac data). Two different approaches were tested: using both stacks of 2-D axial slices and using 3-D data (with the appropriate changes in the baseline architecture). In the latter approach, thanks to the 3-D convolution operator, all the information underlying 3-D data can be exploited. Once the training was completed using 80 cardiac data, a post-processing step was applied on 20 predicted segmentations belonging to the test set.
By applying the 2-D and 3-D approaches, average Dice coefficient and mean Hausdorff distances were 0.896, 0.914, and 8.98 mm, 8.34 mm, respectively. Volumes of the anatomical LA meshes from the automated analysis were highly correlated with the volumes from ground truth [2-D: r=0.978, y=0.94x+0.07, bias=3.5 ml (5.6%), SD=5.3 mL (8.5%); 3-D: r=0.982, y=0.92x+2.9, bias=2.1 mL (3.5%), SD=5.2 mL (8.4%)].
These results suggest the proposed approach is feasible and provides accurate results. Despite the increase of the number of trainable parameters, the proposed 3-D CNN learns better features leading to higher performance, feasible for a real clinical application.
多项研究表明,评估左心房(LA)纤维化对于评估心房颤动(AF)导管消融的合适策略是一项相关信息。延迟钆增强(LGE)心脏磁共振成像(MRI)是一种非侵入性技术,可用于对AF患者的LA心肌纤维化组织进行非侵入性定量分析。目前,LGE MRI的分析依赖于手动描绘LA边界,鉴于观察者经验程度、LA壁厚度和数据分辨率的不同,该过程耗时且易于出现较高的观察者间变异性。因此,非常需要一种用于定量瘢痕组织的心房腔自动分割方法。
本研究专注于设计一个全自动LGE MRI分割流程,该流程包括基于成功架构U-Net的卷积神经网络(CNN)。使用来自2018年心脏统计图谱与计算建模心房分割挑战赛(100个心脏数据)的可用数据对CNN进行端到端的训练、验证和测试。测试了两种不同的方法:使用2-D轴向切片堆栈和使用3-D数据(对基线架构进行适当更改)。在后一种方法中,由于3-D卷积算子,可以利用3-D数据的所有基础信息。使用80个心脏数据完成训练后,对属于测试集的20个预测分割进行后处理步骤。
通过应用2-D和3-D方法,平均Dice系数和平均豪斯多夫距离分别为0.896、0.�14和8.98毫米、8.34毫米。自动分析得到的解剖学LA网格体积与真实体积高度相关[2-D:r = 0.978,y = 0.94x + 0.07,偏差 = 3.5毫升(5.6%),标准差 = 5.3毫升(8.5%);3-D:r = 0.982,y = 0.92x + 2.9,偏差 = 2.1毫升(3.5%),标准差 = 5.2毫升(8.4%)]。
这些结果表明所提出的方法是可行的,并能提供准确的结果。尽管可训练参数数量增加,但所提出的3-D CNN能更好地学习特征,从而实现更高的性能,适用于实际临床应用。