School of Population Health, University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, United States.
Department of Psychology, University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, United States.
Front Public Health. 2021 May 5;9:583491. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.583491. eCollection 2021.
Handwashing has been widely recommended to reduce the spread of COVID-19. Despite this, handwashing behavior remains low in the general public. Social marketing has been employed as a successful health promotion strategy for changing many health behaviors in the past. The present study examines if message framing influences the effectiveness of a handwashing health promotion messages at the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. In a between-subjects cross-sectional experiment, participants ( = 344) in the United States were randomly assigned to view one of four handwashing messages or a control message before completing self-report measures of attitudes, emotions, readiness to change, and behavioral intentions around handwashing. Simple handwashing messages were presented with different framings, including a simple exchange message, a gain message, a social norm appeal, and a guilt appeal. Results revealed that message type influenced handwashing behavioral intentions and emotions. comparisons revealed that the simple exchange message produced significantly higher intentions than other messages and that only the simple exchange message significantly differed from the control message on emotions regarding handwashing. Mediational analyses showed handwashing emotions fully mediated the relationship between messaging and handwashing intentions. This mediation effect was moderated by age, such that it occurred for the younger and middle age participants, but not older participants. These results suggest that even simple, brief, and easily conveyable messages can positively impact behavioral intentions around handwashing during the early stages of a health crisis. Consistent with recent research comparing affective and cognitive pathways for health behavior, the mediational analysis suggests that effect of the simple exchange message on intentions was due to increased positive emotions around handwashing.
洗手已被广泛推荐用于减少 COVID-19 的传播。尽管如此,公众的洗手行为仍然很低。社会营销过去曾被用作改变许多健康行为的成功健康促进策略。本研究考察了在 COVID-19 大流行早期,信息框架是否会影响洗手健康促进信息的有效性。在一项随机分组的横断面实验中,美国的参与者(n=344)在完成与洗手有关的态度、情绪、改变意愿和行为意向的自我报告测量之前,被随机分配观看四种洗手信息中的一种或一种控制信息。简单的洗手信息采用不同的框架呈现,包括简单的交换信息、收益信息、社会规范呼吁和内疚呼吁。结果表明,信息类型影响洗手的行为意向和情绪。 比较显示,简单的交换信息产生的意图明显高于其他信息,并且只有简单的交换信息在手洗情绪方面与控制信息显著不同。中介分析表明,洗手情绪完全中介了信息传递与洗手意愿之间的关系。这种中介效应受到年龄的调节,对于年轻和中年参与者,但对于老年参与者则没有。这些结果表明,即使是简单、简短和易于传达的信息,也可以在健康危机的早期阶段对洗手的行为意向产生积极影响。与最近比较情感和认知途径对健康行为的研究一致,中介分析表明,简单交换信息对意图的影响是由于对手洗的积极情绪增加所致。