Strauss Clara, Dunkeld Charlotte, Cavanagh Kate
Sussex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Research Department, Sussex Education Centre, Mill View Hospital, Nevill Avenue, Hove, BN3 7HY, UK.
School of Psychology, University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton, BN1 9QH, UK.
Internet Interv. 2021 Jun 5;25:100413. doi: 10.1016/j.invent.2021.100413. eCollection 2021 Sep.
Depression is the leading cause of disability globally and has serious consequences for the individual, their family and for society. Effective, accessible and affordable treatments are urgently needed. In-person group-based mindfulness-based interventions are an effective treatment for depression, but are not widely available and can be costly. Clinician supported use of mindfulness self-help resources such as mindfulness smartphone applications could widen access at a reduced cost, but there are key feasibility questions that need answering. This is a mixed-methods feasibility study of a blended intervention involving the mindfulness smartphone app Headspace alongside six clinician support sessions with mental health treatment seeking adults experiencing moderate to moderately severe symptoms of depression. In line with recommendations for feasibility studies, we examine whether: (1) it is possible to recruit participants to this novel intervention, (2) participants engage with the intervention, (3) participants and clinicians find the intervention acceptable, and (4) pre-post outcomes on measures of depression (primary outcome), anxiety, wellbeing, mindfulness, self-compassion, rumination and worry indicate effectiveness. Findings show that recruitment is feasible with 54 participants enrolled in the intervention within a 6-month window. In terms of engagement, 44.4% completed at least 80% of recommended Headspace sessions and 72.2% of participants attended at least three clinician support sessions. Clinician-supported Headspace was deemed acceptable by participants and clinicians. Pre-post effect sizes were statistically significant and in the small-medium or medium-large range on all outcomes, with an effect size of = 0.69 (95% CI: 0.34-1.04) for the primary outcome of depression symptom severity. The number of Headspace sessions engaged with was associated with greater reduction in depression symptom severity. Findings suggest that a blended intervention combining Headspace with clinician support has potential as a first-line treatment for moderate/moderately severe depression, but findings are too preliminary to recommend the intervention outside of a research trial. Important caveats are noted including the need for future research to examine predictors of engagement with Headspace sessions so that engagement can be enhanced, to measure the longer term effects of such interventions and to better understand the potential for lasting negative effects of the intervention so that these can be minimised.
抑郁症是全球致残的主要原因,对个人、其家庭和社会都有严重影响。迫切需要有效、可及且负担得起的治疗方法。基于正念的面对面团体干预是治疗抑郁症的有效方法,但并未广泛普及且成本高昂。临床医生支持使用正念自助资源,如正念智能手机应用程序,可能会以较低成本扩大治疗的可及性,但存在一些关键的可行性问题需要解答。这是一项混合方法的可行性研究,涉及一种混合干预措施,即使用正念智能手机应用程序Headspace,并为寻求心理健康治疗、有中度至中度严重抑郁症状的成年人提供六次临床医生支持课程。根据可行性研究的建议,我们研究以下方面:(1)是否有可能招募参与者参加这种新型干预措施;(2)参与者是否参与该干预措施;(3)参与者和临床医生是否认为该干预措施可接受;(4)抑郁(主要结果)、焦虑、幸福感、正念、自我同情、反刍和担忧等测量指标的前后结果是否表明该干预措施有效。研究结果表明,招募是可行的,在6个月内有54名参与者参加了该干预措施。在参与度方面,44.4%的参与者完成了至少推荐的80%的Headspace课程,72.2%的参与者参加了至少三次临床医生支持课程。参与者和临床医生都认为临床医生支持的Headspace是可接受的。前后效应量在所有结果上均具有统计学意义,且处于小至中或中至大范围内,抑郁症状严重程度这一主要结果的效应量为d = 0.69(95%置信区间:0.34 - 1.04)。参与的Headspace课程数量与抑郁症状严重程度的更大降低相关。研究结果表明,将Headspace与临床医生支持相结合的混合干预措施有潜力作为中度/中度严重抑郁症的一线治疗方法,但研究结果过于初步,无法在研究试验之外推荐该干预措施。需要注意一些重要的限制条件,包括未来研究需要检查参与Headspace课程的预测因素,以便提高参与度,测量此类干预措施的长期效果,并更好地了解该干预措施可能产生的持久负面影响,从而将这些影响降至最低。