Disease Elimination Program, Burnet Institute, 85 Commercial Rd, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
BMC Public Health. 2023 May 27;23(1):988. doi: 10.1186/s12889-023-15936-w.
Policy responses to COVID-19 in Victoria, Australia over 2020-2021 have been supported by evidence generated through mathematical modelling. This study describes the design, key findings, and process for policy translation of a series of modelling studies conducted for the Victorian Department of Health COVID-19 response team during this period.
An agent-based model, Covasim, was used to simulate the impact of policy interventions on COVID-19 outbreaks and epidemic waves. The model was continually adapted to enable scenario analysis of settings or policies being considered at the time (e.g. elimination of community transmission versus disease control). Model scenarios were co-designed with government, to fill evidence gaps prior to key decisions.
Understanding outbreak risk following incursions was critical to eliminating community COVID-19 transmission. Analyses showed risk depended on whether the first detected case was the index case, a primary contact of the index case, or a 'mystery case'. There were benefits of early lockdown on first case detection and gradual easing of restrictions to minimise resurgence risk from undetected cases. As vaccination coverage increased and the focus shifted to controlling rather than eliminating community transmission, understanding health system demand was critical. Analyses showed that vaccines alone could not protect health systems and need to be complemented with other public health measures.
Model evidence offered the greatest value when decisions needed to be made pre-emptively, or for questions that could not be answered with empiric data and data analysis alone. Co-designing scenarios with policy-makers ensured relevance and increased policy translation.
澳大利亚维多利亚州在 2020-2021 年期间针对 COVID-19 的政策响应得到了通过数学建模生成的证据的支持。本研究描述了在此期间为维多利亚州卫生部 COVID-19 应对小组进行的一系列建模研究的设计、主要发现和政策转化过程。
使用基于代理的 Covasim 模型来模拟政策干预对 COVID-19 爆发和疫情波的影响。该模型不断进行调整,以能够对当时正在考虑的情况或政策(例如消除社区传播与疾病控制)进行情景分析。模型情景与政府共同设计,在做出关键决策之前填补证据空白。
了解传入事件后爆发的风险对于消除社区 COVID-19 传播至关重要。分析表明,风险取决于第一个检测到的病例是索引病例、索引病例的主要接触者还是“神秘病例”。早期封锁对第一例病例的检测和逐步放宽限制以最小化未检测到的病例引起的复发风险有好处。随着疫苗接种覆盖率的提高,以及控制而不是消除社区传播的重点转移,了解卫生系统的需求至关重要。分析表明,仅靠疫苗无法保护卫生系统,需要结合其他公共卫生措施。
当需要预先做出决策或仅凭经验数据和数据分析无法回答问题时,模型证据最具价值。与政策制定者共同设计情景确保了相关性并增加了政策转化。