Vandendriessche Ann, Deforche Benedicte, Dhondt Karlien, Altenburg Teatske M, Verloigne Maïté
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Movement and Nutrition for Health and Performance Research Group, Faculty of Physical Education and Physical Therapy, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium.
Health Promot Perspect. 2023 Dec 16;13(4):316-329. doi: 10.34172/hpp.2023.37. eCollection 2023.
Adolescents' sleep deteriorated over the last decades, urging the need to develop effective interventions. Using participatory action research (PAR) is a promising and unique approach to target adolescents' sleep. This study aims to describe the process and results of combining PAR and intervention mapping (IM) to guide future researchers on developing and planning of the implementation and evaluation of interventions promoting healthy sleep in adolescents.
In each of three intervention schools (two with general and technical education and one with technical and vocational education), an action team including adolescents (age 13- 15 years, n=max. 12) and a researcher was composed to develop and plan the intervention. During weekly sessions (n=ranging from 23 to 34 per school), the action team went through the six steps of IM. A short PAR was performed with parents (n=7) to develop parental intervention components.
Combining PAR and IM resulted in interventions focusing on the importance of healthy sleep, regular sleep patterns and associated behaviors: screen behaviors, physical activity, dietary behavior and relaxation. Several differences in the participatory process (i.e. more guidance needed during brainstorms in the vocational/technical school) and developed intervention (i.e. less intrusive intervention components in the vocational/technical school) were observed between schools.
Combining PAR with IM resulted in more extensive interventions than other existing school-based sleep interventions. Future studies should investigate whether a participatory developed sleep intervention could be transferred to another setting using a shorter participatory process.
在过去几十年中,青少年的睡眠质量有所下降,因此迫切需要开发有效的干预措施。采用参与式行动研究(PAR)是针对青少年睡眠问题的一种有前景且独特的方法。本研究旨在描述将PAR与干预映射(IM)相结合的过程和结果,为未来研究人员开展和规划促进青少年健康睡眠的干预措施的实施与评估提供指导。
在三所干预学校中的每一所(两所提供普通教育和技术教育,一所提供技术和职业教育),组建了一个包括青少年(13 - 15岁,最多12名)和一名研究人员的行动团队,以开发和规划干预措施。在每周的会议期间(每所学校会议次数从23次到34次不等),行动团队经历了IM的六个步骤。与家长(7名)进行了简短的PAR,以制定家长干预部分。
将PAR和IM相结合产生了侧重于健康睡眠的重要性、规律睡眠模式及相关行为的干预措施:屏幕使用行为、体育活动、饮食行为和放松。在参与过程(即职业/技术学校在头脑风暴期间需要更多指导)和所开发的干预措施(即职业/技术学校的干预部分侵入性较小)方面,不同学校之间存在一些差异。
与其他现有的基于学校的睡眠干预措施相比,将PAR与IM相结合产生了更广泛的干预措施。未来的研究应调查通过较短的参与过程,参与式开发的睡眠干预措施是否可以转移到另一种环境中。