Navakauskas Dalius, Dumpis Martynas
Department of Electronic Systems, Vilnius Gediminas Technical University, Plytines g. 25-234, LT-10105 Vilnius, Lithuania.
Sensors (Basel). 2025 Jul 16;25(14):4420. doi: 10.3390/s25144420.
Human Activity Recognition (HAR) using wearable sensor data is increasingly important in healthcare, rehabilitation, and smart monitoring. This study systematically compared three dynamic neural network architectures-Finite Impulse Response Neural Network (FIRNN), Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM), and Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU)-to examine their suitability and specificity for HAR tasks. A controlled experimental setup was applied, training 16,500 models across different delay lengths and hidden neuron counts. The investigation focused on classification accuracy, computational cost, and model interpretability. LSTM achieved the highest classification accuracy (98.76%), followed by GRU (97.33%) and FIRNN (95.74%), with FIRNN offering the lowest computational complexity. To improve model transparency, Layer-wise Relevance Propagation (LRP) was applied to both input and hidden layers. The results showed that gyroscope Y-axis data was consistently the most informative, while accelerometer Y-axis data was the least informative. LRP analysis also revealed that GRU distributed relevance more broadly across hidden units, while FIRNN relied more on a small subset. These findings highlight trade-offs between performance, complexity, and interpretability and provide practical guidance for applying explainable neural wearable sensor-based HAR.
利用可穿戴传感器数据进行人体活动识别(HAR)在医疗保健、康复和智能监测中变得越来越重要。本研究系统地比较了三种动态神经网络架构——有限脉冲响应神经网络(FIRNN)、长短期记忆网络(LSTM)和门控循环单元(GRU),以检验它们对HAR任务的适用性和特异性。采用了一个受控实验装置,在不同延迟长度和隐藏神经元数量下训练了16500个模型。研究重点在于分类准确率、计算成本和模型可解释性。LSTM实现了最高的分类准确率(98.76%),其次是GRU(97.33%)和FIRNN(95.74%),其中FIRNN的计算复杂度最低。为了提高模型透明度,对输入层和隐藏层都应用了逐层相关传播(LRP)。结果表明,陀螺仪Y轴数据始终是信息最丰富的,而加速度计Y轴数据的信息量最少。LRP分析还表明,GRU在隐藏单元之间更广泛地分布相关性,而FIRNN更多地依赖于一小部分单元。这些发现突出了性能、复杂性和可解释性之间的权衡,并为应用基于可解释神经可穿戴传感器的HAR提供了实际指导。