Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, 11720 Beltsville Drive, Suite 900, Calverton, MD 20705-3111, USA.
J Safety Res. 2014 Feb;48:103-10. doi: 10.1016/j.jsr.2013.12.008. Epub 2014 Jan 4.
About 20years ago, concern was raised about the dangers that children face when driven by drinking drivers in the United States. During the last decade, the pace of research on this topic subsided. Yet in 2010, every day three children younger than age 15 were killed, and 469 were injured in motor-vehicle crashes.
The aim of this effort is to describe the status of the problem in the United States and suggest lines of research. From the Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS), we selected crashes in which a driver aged 21 or older was driving at least one child younger than age 15. We identified crashes that occurred at different times of the day in which the driver was speeding, ran a red light, or was alcohol positive. We described the drivers' demographics and examined how they relate to the different crash types.
We found that, although driving a child seems to protect against the studied forms of risky driving, such protection varies sharply depending upon the drivers' and children's demographics and the crash type. There is no clear reason to explain the drivers' decision to endanger the children that they drive. The percent of children killed in speeding-related and red-light running motor-vehicle crashes has remained relatively stable during the last decade. Future research must (a) examine the effectiveness of current child endangerment laws; (b) examine crashes other than fatal; and (c) be more targeted, looking at specific drivers' age and gender, specific children's ages, the time of the crash, and the type of crash.
Significant attention needs to be given towards improving state laws on child endangerment. Policymakers' reaction to this problem is tentative because of our limited understanding of the problem; therefore, further research is needed. With unfocused countermeasures and prevention efforts, we have been restricted in our ability to evaluate these responses. The findings of this report should be informative to policy makers.
大约 20 年前,人们开始关注美国儿童在醉酒司机驾驶时所面临的危险。在过去的十年中,针对这一主题的研究步伐有所放缓。然而,在 2010 年,每天仍有 3 名 15 岁以下的儿童死于机动车事故,469 名儿童受伤。
本研究旨在描述美国这一问题的现状,并提出研究方向。我们从 Fatality Analysis Reporting System(FARS)中选择了驾驶员年龄在 21 岁或以上,且至少载有一名 15 岁以下儿童的撞车事故。我们确定了在一天中不同时间发生的撞车事故,这些事故的驾驶员存在超速、闯红灯或酒后驾车的情况。我们描述了驾驶员的人口统计学特征,并研究了它们与不同类型撞车事故的关系。
我们发现,虽然驾驶儿童似乎可以防止研究中出现的危险驾驶行为,但这种保护作用因驾驶员和儿童的人口统计学特征以及撞车类型的不同而有很大差异。没有明显的理由可以解释驾驶员为何要危及他们所驾驶的儿童。在过去十年中,与超速和闯红灯相关的儿童死亡比例以及机动车事故一直相对稳定。未来的研究必须:(a)研究现行儿童危害法的有效性;(b)研究除致命事故以外的事故;(c)更有针对性地研究特定驾驶员的年龄和性别、特定儿童的年龄、撞车时间和撞车类型。
需要高度重视完善关于儿童危害的州法律。由于我们对这一问题的了解有限,决策者对这一问题的反应是试探性的,因此需要进一步研究。由于缺乏有针对性的对策和预防措施,我们在评估这些应对措施的能力上受到了限制。本报告的研究结果应该为决策者提供信息。