Thordardottir Elin
McGill University, School of Communication Sciences and Disorders , Montréal, Quebec , Canada.
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2015 Apr;17(2):97-114. doi: 10.3109/17549507.2014.923509. Epub 2014 Jul 16.
The study examined the effect of bilingual input on the grammatical development of bilingual children in comparison to monolingual peers.
Spontaneous language samples were collected in English and French from typically-developing bilingual and monolingual pre-schoolers aged 3 years (n = 56) and 5 years (n = 83). Within each age group, children varied in bilingual exposure patterns but were matched on age, non-verbal cognition, maternal education and language status, speaking two majority languages. Measures included mean length of utterance (MLU) in words and morphemes, and accuracy and diversity of morphological use.
Grammatical development in each language was strongly influenced by amount of same-language experience. Children with equal exposure to both languages scored comparably to monolingual children in both languages, whereas children with unequal exposure evidenced similarly unequal performance across languages and scored significantly lower than monolinguals in their weaker language. Scoring significantly lower than monolinguals in both languages may, therefore, be a sign of language impairment. Each language followed a strongly language-specific sequence of acquisition and error patterns. Five-year-old children with low exposure to English displayed an optional infinitive pattern, a strong clinical marker for Primary Language Impairment in monolingual English-speaking children.
Descriptive normative data are presented that permit more accurate interpretation of bilingual assessment data.
本研究考察了双语输入对双语儿童语法发展的影响,并与单语同龄人进行了比较。
从3岁(n = 56)和5岁(n = 83)发育正常的双语和单语学龄前儿童中收集英语和法语的自发语言样本。在每个年龄组中,儿童的双语接触模式各不相同,但在年龄、非语言认知、母亲教育程度和语言状况方面相匹配,均会说两种主要语言。测量指标包括以单词和语素计算的平均语句长度(MLU)以及形态学使用准确性和多样性。
每种语言的语法发展都受到相同语言经验量的强烈影响。两种语言接触量相等的儿童在两种语言上的得分与单语儿童相当,而接触量不等的儿童在两种语言上的表现也同样不均衡,在较弱语言上的得分显著低于单语儿童。因此,在两种语言上得分均显著低于单语儿童可能是语言障碍的一个迹象。每种语言都遵循强烈的特定语言习得顺序和错误模式。英语接触量少的5岁儿童表现出可选不定式模式,这是单语英语儿童原发性语言障碍的一个重要临床指标。
提供了描述性规范数据,有助于更准确地解释双语评估数据。