Kola Mehmet, Duran Hikmet, Turk Adem, Mollamehmetoglu Suleyman, Kalkisim Ahmet, Erdol Hidayet
Department of Ophthalmology, Faculty of Medicine, Karadeniz Technical University, 61080 Trabzon, Turkey.
J Ophthalmol. 2014;2014:739652. doi: 10.1155/2014/739652. Epub 2014 Jul 22.
Purpose. To assess the repeatability and reproducibility of ocular biometry and intraocular lens (IOL) power measurements obtained by ophthalmology residents using an AL-Scan device, a novel optical biometer. Methods. Two ophthalmology residents were instructed regarding the AL-Scan device. Both performed ocular biometry and IOL power measurements using AL-Scan, three times on each of 128 eyes, independently of one another. Corneal keratometry readings, horizontal iris width, central corneal thickness, anterior chamber depth, pupil size, and axial length values measured by both residents were recorded together with IOL power values calculated on the basis of four different IOL calculation formulas (SRK/T, Holladay, and HofferQ). Repeatability and reproducibility of the measurements obtained were analyzed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Results. Repeatability (ICC, 0.872-0.999 for resident 1 versus 0.905-0.999 for resident 2) and reproducibility (ICC, 0.916-0.999) were high for all biometric measurements. Repeatability (ICC, 0.981-0.983 for resident 1 versus 0.995-0.996 for resident 2) and reproducibility were also high for all IOL power measurements (ICC, 0.996 for all). Conclusions. The AL-Scan device exhibits good repeatability and reproducibility in all biometric measurements and IOL power calculations, independent of the operator concerned.
目的。评估眼科住院医师使用新型光学生物测量仪AL-Scan设备进行眼生物测量和人工晶状体(IOL)屈光度测量的重复性和再现性。方法。对两名眼科住院医师进行了关于AL-Scan设备的指导。两人均使用AL-Scan对128只眼睛中的每只眼睛独立进行三次眼生物测量和IOL屈光度测量。记录两名住院医师测量的角膜曲率读数、水平虹膜宽度、中央角膜厚度、前房深度、瞳孔大小和眼轴长度值,以及基于四种不同IOL计算公式(SRK/T、Holladay和HofferQ)计算出的IOL屈光度值。使用组内相关系数(ICC)分析所获得测量值的重复性和再现性。结果。所有生物测量的重复性(住院医师1的ICC为0.872 - 0.999,住院医师2的ICC为0.905 - 0.999)和再现性(ICC为0.916 - 0.999)都很高。所有IOL屈光度测量值的重复性(住院医师1的ICC为0.981 - 0.983,住院医师2的ICC为0.995 - 0.996)和再现性也很高(所有的ICC为0.996)。结论。AL-Scan设备在所有生物测量和IOL屈光度计算中均表现出良好的重复性和再现性,与相关操作人员无关。