Hu Guoqiang, Waters Abigail B, Aslan Serdar, Frederick Blaise, Cong Fengyu, Nickerson Lisa D
School of Biomedical Engineering, Faculty of Electronic Information and Electrical Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China.
Brain Imaging Center, Mclean Hospital, Belmont, MA, United States.
Front Neurosci. 2020 Sep 18;14:569657. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2020.569657. eCollection 2020.
In independent component analysis (ICA), the selection of model order (i.e., number of components to be extracted) has crucial effects on functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) brain network analysis. Model order selection (MOS) algorithms have been used to determine the number of estimated components. However, simulations show that even when the model order equals the number of simulated signal sources, traditional ICA algorithms may misestimate the spatial maps of the signal sources. In principle, increasing model order will consider more potential information in the estimation, and should therefore produce more accurate results. However, this strategy may not work for fMRI because large-scale networks are widely spatially distributed and thus have increased mutual information with noise. As such, conventional ICA algorithms with high model orders may not extract these components at all. This conflict makes the selection of model order a problem. We present a new strategy for model order free ICA, called Snowball ICA, that obviates these issues. The algorithm collects all information for each network from fMRI data without the limitations of network scale. Using simulations and resting-state fMRI data, our results show that component estimation using Snowball ICA is more accurate than traditional ICA. The Snowball ICA software is available at https://github.com/GHu-DUT/Snowball-ICA.
在独立成分分析(ICA)中,模型阶数(即要提取的成分数量)的选择对功能磁共振成像(fMRI)脑网络分析有着至关重要的影响。模型阶数选择(MOS)算法已被用于确定估计成分的数量。然而,模拟结果表明,即使模型阶数等于模拟信号源的数量,传统的ICA算法也可能会错误估计信号源的空间图谱。原则上,增加模型阶数会在估计中考虑更多潜在信息,因此应该能产生更准确的结果。然而,这种策略在fMRI中可能并不适用,因为大规模网络在空间上分布广泛,因此与噪声的互信息增加。因此,具有高模型阶数的传统ICA算法可能根本无法提取这些成分。这种冲突使得模型阶数的选择成为一个问题。我们提出了一种新的无模型阶数ICA策略,称为雪球ICA,它避免了这些问题。该算法从fMRI数据中收集每个网络的所有信息,不受网络规模的限制。通过模拟和静息态fMRI数据,我们的结果表明,使用雪球ICA进行成分估计比传统ICA更准确。雪球ICA软件可在https://github.com/GHu-DUT/Snowball-ICA获取。