Department of Medical Education, Ege University Faculty of Medicine, Izmir, Türkiye.
Department of Management Information Systems, Izmir Democracy University Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Izmir, Türkiye.
PLoS One. 2022 Jul 21;17(7):e0271872. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0271872. eCollection 2022.
Artificial intelligence (AI) has affected our day-to-day in a great extent. Healthcare industry is one of the mainstream fields among those and produced a noticeable change in treatment and education. Medical students must comprehend well why AI technologies mediate and frame their decisions on medical issues. Formalizing of instruction on AI concepts can facilitate learners to grasp AI outcomes in association with their sensory perceptions and thinking in the dynamic and ambiguous reality of daily medical practice. The purpose of this study is to provide consensus on the competencies required by medical graduates to be ready for artificial intelligence technologies and possible applications in medicine and reporting the results.
A three-round e-Delphi survey was conducted between February 2020 and November 2020. The Delphi panel accorporated experts from different backgrounds; (i) healthcare professionals/ academicians; (ii) computer and data science professionals/ academics; (iii) law and ethics professionals/ academics; and (iv) medical students. Round 1 in the Delphi survey began with exploratory open-ended questions. Responses received in the first round evaluated and refined to a 27-item questionnaire which then sent to the experts to be rated using a 7-point Likert type scale (1: Strongly Disagree-7: Strongly Agree). Similar to the second round, the participants repeated their assessments in the third round by using the second-round analysis. The agreement level and strength of the consensus was decided based on third phase results. Median scores was used to calculate the agreement level and the interquartile range (IQR) was used for determining the strength of the consensus.
Among 128 invitees, a total of 94 agreed to become members of the expert panel. Of them 75 (79.8%) completed the Round 1 questionnaire, 69/75 (92.0%) completed the Round 2 and 60/69 (87.0%) responded to the Round 3. There was a strong agreement on the 23 items and weak agreement on the 4 items.
This study has provided a consensus list of the competencies required by the medical graduates to be ready for AI implications that would bring new perspectives to medical education curricula. The unique feature of the current research is providing a guiding role in integrating AI into curriculum processes, syllabus content and training of medical students.
人工智能(AI)在很大程度上影响了我们的日常生活。医疗保健行业是其中的主流领域之一,在治疗和教育方面带来了显著的变化。医学生必须充分理解为什么 AI 技术会影响他们对医疗问题的决策。对 AI 概念进行正式的教学可以帮助学习者在动态和模糊的日常医疗实践中,将 AI 结果与其感官感知和思维联系起来。本研究的目的是就医学毕业生为人工智能技术做好准备所需的能力达成共识,并报告研究结果。
在 2020 年 2 月至 2020 年 11 月期间,进行了三轮电子德尔菲调查。德尔菲小组由来自不同背景的专家组成;(一)医疗保健专业人员/学者;(二)计算机和数据科学专业人员/学者;(三)法律和伦理专业人员/学者;(四)医学生。第一轮德尔菲调查从探索性的开放式问题开始。第一轮收到的回复经过评估和提炼,形成了 27 项问卷,然后分发给专家,让他们使用 7 点李克特量表(1:强烈不同意-7:强烈同意)进行评分。与第二轮一样,参与者在第三轮中根据第二轮的分析重复评估。根据第三阶段的结果确定共识的一致性水平和强度。使用中位数分数计算一致性水平,使用四分位距(IQR)确定共识的强度。
在 128 名受邀者中,共有 94 人同意成为专家小组的成员。其中 75 人(79.8%)完成了第一轮问卷,69/75(92.0%)完成了第二轮问卷,60/69(87.0%)完成了第三轮问卷。23 项内容达成强烈共识,4 项内容达成弱共识。
本研究提供了医学生为 AI 影响做好准备所需的能力的共识清单,这将为医学教育课程带来新的视角。当前研究的独特之处在于为将 AI 纳入课程流程、教学大纲内容和医学生培训提供指导作用。