Tandel Gopal S, Tiwari Ashish, Kakde Omprakash G, Gupta Neha, Saba Luca, Suri Jasjit S
School of Computer Science and Engineering, VIT Bhopal University, Sehore 466114, India.
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Visvesvaraya National Institute of Technology, Nagpur 440010, India.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2023 Jan 28;13(3):481. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics13030481.
The biopsy is a gold standard method for tumor grading. However, due to its invasive nature, it has sometimes proved fatal for brain tumor patients. As a result, a non-invasive computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) tool is required. Recently, many magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-based CAD tools have been proposed for brain tumor grading. The MRI has several sequences, which can express tumor structure in different ways. However, a suitable MRI sequence for brain tumor classification is not yet known. The most common brain tumor is 'glioma', which is the most fatal form. Therefore, in the proposed study, to maximize the classification ability between low-grade versus high-grade glioma, three datasets were designed comprising three MRI sequences: T1-Weighted (T1W), T2-weighted (T2W), and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR). Further, five well-established convolutional neural networks, AlexNet, VGG16, ResNet18, GoogleNet, and ResNet50 were adopted for tumor classification. An ensemble algorithm was proposed using the majority vote of above five deep learning (DL) models to produce more consistent and improved results than any individual model. Five-fold cross validation (K5-CV) protocol was adopted for training and testing. For the proposed ensembled classifier with K5-CV, the highest test accuracies of 98.88 ± 0.63%, 97.98 ± 0.86%, and 94.75 ± 0.61% were achieved for FLAIR, T2W, and T1W-MRI data, respectively. FLAIR-MRI data was found to be most significant for brain tumor classification, where it showed a 4.17% and 0.91% improvement in accuracy against the T1W-MRI and T2W-MRI sequence data, respectively. The proposed ensembled algorithm (MajVot) showed significant improvements in the average accuracy of three datasets of 3.60%, 2.84%, 1.64%, 4.27%, and 1.14%, respectively, against AlexNet, VGG16, ResNet18, GoogleNet, and ResNet50.
活检是肿瘤分级的金标准方法。然而,由于其侵入性,有时已证明对脑肿瘤患者是致命的。因此,需要一种非侵入性的计算机辅助诊断(CAD)工具。最近,已经提出了许多基于磁共振成像(MRI)的CAD工具用于脑肿瘤分级。MRI有几个序列,可以以不同方式表达肿瘤结构。然而,尚未知道用于脑肿瘤分类的合适MRI序列。最常见的脑肿瘤是“胶质瘤”,这是最致命的形式。因此,在本研究中,为了最大化低级别与高级别胶质瘤之间的分类能力,设计了三个数据集,包括三个MRI序列:T1加权(T1W)、T2加权(T2W)和液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)。此外,采用了五个成熟的卷积神经网络,即AlexNet、VGG16、ResNet18、GoogleNet和ResNet50进行肿瘤分类。提出了一种集成算法,使用上述五个深度学习(DL)模型的多数投票来产生比任何单个模型更一致和更好的结果。采用五折交叉验证(K5-CV)协议进行训练和测试。对于采用K5-CV的所提出的集成分类器,对于FLAIR、T2W和T1W-MRI数据,分别实现了98.88±0.63%、97.98±0.86%和94.75±0.61%的最高测试准确率。发现FLAIR-MRI数据对脑肿瘤分类最为重要,相对于T1W-MRI和T2W-MRI序列数据,其准确率分别提高了4.17%和0.91%。所提出的集成算法(MajVot)相对于AlexNet、VGG16、ResNet18、GoogleNet和ResNet50,在三个数据集的平均准确率上分别有3.60%、2.84%、1.64%、4.27%和1.14%的显著提高。