Hurlbut B I, Iwata B A, Green J D
J Appl Behav Anal. 1982 Summer;15(2):241-58. doi: 10.1901/jaba.1982.15-241.
This study compared training in two language systems for three severely handicapped, nonvocal adolescents: the Bliss symbol system and an iconic picture system. Following baseline, training and review trials were implemented using an alternating treatments design. Daily probes were conducted to assess maintenance, stimulus generalization, and response generalization, and data were collected on spontaneous usage of either language system throughout the school day. Results showed that students required approximately four times as many trials to acquire Bliss symbols as iconic pictures, and that students maintained a higher percentage of iconic pictures. Stimulus generalization occurred in both language systems, while the number of correct responses during responses generalization probes was much greater for the iconic system. Finally, students almost always showed more iconic responses than Bliss responses in daily spontaneous usage. These results suggest that an iconic system might be more readily spontaneous usage. These results suggest than an iconic system might be more readily acquired, maintained, and generalized to daily situations. Implications of these findings for the newly verbal person were discussed.
本研究比较了针对三名严重残疾、不会说话的青少年的两种语言系统训练:布利斯符号系统和图标图片系统。在基线之后,采用交替治疗设计实施训练和复习试验。每天进行探测以评估保持、刺激泛化和反应泛化,并收集学生在整个上学日对任一语言系统自发使用的数据。结果表明,学生掌握布利斯符号所需的试验次数大约是图标图片的四倍,并且学生对图标图片的保持率更高。两种语言系统均出现了刺激泛化,而在反应泛化探测期间,图标系统的正确反应数量要多得多。最后,在日常自发使用中,学生几乎总是表现出比布利斯反应更多的图标反应。这些结果表明,图标系统可能更容易被自发使用。这些结果表明,图标系统可能更容易被习得、保持并推广到日常情境中。讨论了这些发现对新学会说话者的意义。