Ren X S, Amick B C
Health Institute, New England Medical Centre, Boston, MA 02111, USA.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 1996 Jun;50(3):269-73. doi: 10.1136/jech.50.3.269.
To estimate relative odds ratios and to ascertain the relative contribution of each socioeconomic covariate in explaining racial disparities in self assessed health status (for example, global health perceptions and functional limitations of daily activities).
National representative data from the 1987-88 national survey of families and households, a multistage, stratified probability sample of non-institutionalised American adults age 19 and older, were used. Logistic regression models enabled a multistage building strategy to be used in the analyses.
The study included three racial groups: whites (n = 9419), blacks (n = 2391), and Hispanics (n = 1004). While face to face interviews were carried out with each respondent, some portions of the interview were self administered to collect sensitive information.
Compared with whites, blacks and Hispanics were more likely to assess health as poor and report having functional limitations of daily activities. Socioeconomic factors tended to play a different role in explaining racial disparities in self assessed health status. In global health, education tended to play a significant role in accounting for health disparities between whites and Hispanics. In functional limitations, none of the covariates explained racial differences for blacks, whereas for Hispanics, education and marital status explained racial differences.
The debate over whether race is a proxy for socioeconomic conditions or race influences health independent of socioeconomic factors depends on the measure of health and racial group included in the study. Future studies should examine separately the differential impacts of various socioeconomic factors on varying domains of health.
估计相对比值比,并确定每个社会经济协变量在解释自我评估健康状况(例如,整体健康认知和日常活动功能受限情况)方面的种族差异时的相对贡献。
使用了1987 - 1988年全国家庭和住户调查的全国代表性数据,该数据是对19岁及以上非机构化美国成年人的多阶段分层概率样本。逻辑回归模型使分析中能够采用多阶段构建策略。
该研究包括三个种族群体:白人(n = 9419)、黑人(n = 2391)和西班牙裔(n = 1004)。虽然对每位受访者进行了面对面访谈,但部分访谈内容是由受访者自行填写以收集敏感信息。
与白人相比,黑人和西班牙裔更有可能将健康状况评估为较差,并报告存在日常活动功能受限的情况。社会经济因素在解释自我评估健康状况的种族差异时往往发挥不同作用。在整体健康方面,教育在解释白人和西班牙裔之间的健康差异时往往发挥重要作用。在功能受限方面,没有一个协变量能够解释黑人的种族差异,而对于西班牙裔,教育和婚姻状况解释了种族差异。
关于种族是社会经济状况的替代指标还是种族独立于社会经济因素影响健康的争论,取决于研究中所包含的健康衡量指标和种族群体。未来的研究应分别考察各种社会经济因素对不同健康领域的不同影响。