M-Sense Research Group, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA.
Dept. of Computer Science, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA.
Sensors (Basel). 2019 Nov 28;19(23):5227. doi: 10.3390/s19235227.
Wearable sensors have the potential to enable comprehensive patient characterization and optimized clinical intervention. Critical to realizing this vision is accurate estimation of biomechanical time-series in daily-life, including joint, segment, and muscle kinetics and kinematics, from wearable sensor data. The use of physical models for estimation of these quantities often requires many wearable devices making practical implementation more difficult. However, regression techniques may provide a viable alternative by allowing the use of a reduced number of sensors for estimating biomechanical time-series. Herein, we review 46 articles that used regression algorithms to estimate joint, segment, and muscle kinematics and kinetics. We present a high-level comparison of the many different techniques identified and discuss the implications of our findings concerning practical implementation and further improving estimation accuracy. In particular, we found that several studies report the incorporation of domain knowledge often yielded superior performance. Further, most models were trained on small datasets in which case nonparametric regression often performed best. No models were open-sourced, and most were subject-specific and not validated on impaired populations. Future research should focus on developing open-source algorithms using complementary physics-based and machine learning techniques that are validated in clinically impaired populations. This approach may further improve estimation performance and reduce barriers to clinical adoption.
可穿戴传感器具有实现全面患者特征描述和优化临床干预的潜力。实现这一愿景的关键是能够从可穿戴传感器数据中准确估计日常生活中的生物力学时间序列,包括关节、节段和肌肉的运动学和运动学。为了估计这些量,物理模型的使用通常需要许多可穿戴设备,这使得实际实施更加困难。然而,回归技术可以通过允许使用较少的传感器来估计生物力学时间序列,从而提供一种可行的替代方案。在此,我们回顾了 46 篇使用回归算法来估计关节、节段和肌肉运动学和动力学的文章。我们对所确定的许多不同技术进行了高级别比较,并讨论了我们的发现对实际实施和进一步提高估计准确性的影响。特别是,我们发现一些研究报告称,纳入领域知识通常会产生更好的性能。此外,大多数模型都是在小型数据集上进行训练的,在这种情况下,非参数回归通常表现最好。没有模型是开源的,而且大多数都是针对特定个体的,没有在受损人群中进行验证。未来的研究应侧重于使用基于物理学和机器学习的互补技术开发开源算法,并在临床上受损的人群中进行验证。这种方法可能会进一步提高估计性能,并降低临床应用的障碍。