Department of Social Psychology, Basic Psychology, and Methodology, Universidade de Santiago de Compostela (USC), 15782 Santiago de Compostela, Spain.
Department of Methodology of Behavioral Sciences, Faculty of Psychology, Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia (UNED), 28040 Madrid, Spain.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Dec 1;18(23):12687. doi: 10.3390/ijerph182312687.
School bullying continues to be one of the main challenges for the education community. Current research indicates that Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Transsexual, and other LGBT+ people suffer the highest rates of bullying, while other studies suggest that this bullying does not occur based on the victim's actual sexual orientation or gender identity, but because they do not fit into the traditional gender roles. The aim of the present study was to carry out a meta-analytical study on the prevalence of gender-based bullying against LGBT+ schoolchildren and adolescents in Spain.
The review was carried out following the recommendations of the PRISMA group and allowing us to identify a total of 24 studies. All of these studies were published since 2008, and most of them conducted cross-sectional survey-type research. It was also found that the instrument used to assess bullying varied greatly among studies, resulting in an enormous heterogeneity of research on this topic. Different meta-analyses were carried out according to the profile of involvement in bullying: victimisation, perpetration, and observation. In addition, three target populations were detected in the victimisation research: the general population, pre-identified bullying victims reporting the reasons behind the victimisation, and LGBT+ people.
The meta-analyses conducted with R have estimated the prevalence of observation of gender-based school bullying in Spain at 77.3%, perpetration at 13.3%, and victimisation at 8.6% among the general population. When the research focuses on previously identified victims, the rate was 3.6%, while if LGBT+ people are approached directly, the percentage increases to 51%.
These rates reveal the need to develop specific preventive strategies in schools. Greater awareness of affective-sexual diversity and respect for those who do not conform to traditional gender roles should be promoted.
校园欺凌仍是教育界面临的主要挑战之一。目前的研究表明,女同性恋、男同性恋、双性恋、跨性别、变性者和其他性少数群体(LGBT+)遭受欺凌的比例最高,而其他研究表明,这种欺凌并非基于受害者的实际性取向或性别认同,而是因为他们不符合传统的性别角色。本研究旨在对西班牙 LGBT+学童和青少年遭受基于性别的欺凌的流行率进行元分析研究。
本综述遵循 PRISMA 小组的建议进行,共确定了 24 项研究。这些研究均发表于 2008 年以后,其中大多数采用横断面调查研究。研究还发现,评估欺凌的工具在研究之间差异很大,导致对这一主题的研究存在巨大的异质性。根据参与欺凌的情况,进行了不同的元分析:受害者、施害者和观察者。此外,在受害者研究中发现了三个目标人群:一般人群、报告欺凌原因的预先确定的欺凌受害者,以及 LGBT+人群。
使用 R 进行的元分析估计,西班牙一般人群中观察到的基于性别的校园欺凌发生率为 77.3%,施害者为 13.3%,受害者为 8.6%。如果研究关注的是先前确定的受害者,那么这一比例为 3.6%,而如果直接涉及 LGBT+人群,这一比例则上升至 51%。
这些比率表明需要在学校制定具体的预防策略。应该提高对情感性别的多样性的认识,并尊重那些不符合传统性别角色的人。