Buchel Olha, Ninkov Anton, Cathel Danise, Bar-Yam Yaneer, Hedayatifar Leila
New England Complex Systems Institute, 277 Broadway Street, Cambridge, MA, USA.
Faculty of Information and Media Studies, University of Western Ontario, Ontario, Canada.
R Soc Open Sci. 2021 Dec 1;8(12):210865. doi: 10.1098/rsos.210865. eCollection 2021 Dec.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, governments have attempted to control infections within their territories by implementing border controls and lockdowns. While large-scale quarantine has been the most successful short-term policy, the enormous costs exerted by lockdowns over long periods are unsustainable. As such, developing more flexible policies that limit transmission without requiring large-scale quarantine is an urgent priority. Here, the dynamics of dismantled community mobility structures within US society during the COVID-19 outbreak are analysed by applying the Louvain method with modularity optimization to weekly datasets of mobile device locations. Our networks are built based on individuals' movements from February to May 2020. In a multi-scale community detection process using the locations of confirmed cases, natural break points from mobility patterns as well as high risk areas for contagion are identified at three scales. Deviations from administrative boundaries were observed in detected communities, indicating that policies informed by assumptions of disease containment within administrative boundaries do not account for high risk patterns of movement across and through these boundaries. We have designed a multi-level quarantine process that takes these deviations into account based on the heterogeneity in mobility patterns. For communities with high numbers of confirmed cases, contact tracing and associated quarantine policies informed by underlying dismantled community mobility structures is of increasing importance.
在新冠疫情期间,各国政府试图通过实施边境管控和封锁措施来控制本国境内的感染情况。虽然大规模隔离是最成功的短期政策,但长期封锁所带来的巨大成本是不可持续的。因此,制定更灵活的政策以限制传播且无需大规模隔离成为当务之急。在此,通过将具有模块度优化的鲁汶方法应用于移动设备位置的每周数据集,分析了新冠疫情爆发期间美国社会中被拆解的社区流动结构的动态变化。我们的网络基于2020年2月至5月期间个人的移动情况构建。在使用确诊病例位置的多尺度社区检测过程中,在三个尺度上识别出了流动模式的自然断点以及传染的高风险区域。在检测到的社区中观察到与行政边界的偏差,这表明基于行政边界内疾病控制假设的政策并未考虑跨越和穿过这些边界的高风险流动模式。我们设计了一个多级隔离过程,该过程基于流动模式的异质性考虑了这些偏差。对于确诊病例数量较多的社区,基于潜在的被拆解社区流动结构进行接触者追踪及相关隔离政策变得越来越重要。