Cradock-Watson J E, Ridehalgh M K, Pattison J R, Anderson M J, Kangro H O
J Hyg (Lond). 1979 Dec;83(3):413-23. doi: 10.1017/s0022172400026243.
Immunofluorescence (IF) and radioimmunoassay (RIA) have been compared as methods for detecting IgM antibody in 124 infants with confirmed or suspected congenital rubella. IF was used to test sucrose density gradient fractions and RIA to test fractions and whole serum. When fractions were tested IF and RIA were equally specific and distinguished clearly between IgM and IgG, but RIA was the more sensitive method. The RIA titre in whole serum was always greater than in the peak IgM fraction and there was no evidence that testing the serum, rather than the fraction, could result in failure to detect IgM. With some sera RIA gave low titres which became negative after absorption with IgG-coated latex beads. The mechanism of this 'false positive' effect, which may have been due to IgM with anti-IgG activity, was not investigated, but if it can be removed by absorption it need not reduce the specificity of the test. During the first 6 months of life IgM antibody was detected by RIA in 30 out of 32 unfractionated sera and by IF in fractions from 28 of these. After the age of 6 months IgM was found progressively less frequently and the greater sensitivity of RIA became a more obvious advantage: 17 out of 60 specimens were positive by RIA and 11 of these were negative by IF. RIA testing of whole serum appears to be an economical, specific and sensitive method for detecting IgM antibody in congenital rubella, of particular value when the titre of antibody is low.
免疫荧光法(IF)和放射免疫分析法(RIA)被用作检测124例确诊或疑似先天性风疹婴儿体内IgM抗体的方法,并进行了比较。IF用于检测蔗糖密度梯度分离组分,RIA用于检测分离组分和全血清。当检测分离组分时,IF和RIA的特异性相同,能清楚地区分IgM和IgG,但RIA是更灵敏的方法。全血清中的RIA滴度总是高于IgM峰值组分,没有证据表明检测血清而非组分会导致无法检测到IgM。对于一些血清,RIA给出的滴度较低,在用IgG包被的乳胶珠吸收后变为阴性。这种“假阳性”效应的机制可能是由于具有抗IgG活性的IgM,未进行研究,但如果可以通过吸收去除,它不一定会降低检测的特异性。在出生后的前6个月,32份未分离血清中有30份通过RIA检测到IgM抗体,其中28份的分离组分通过IF检测到IgM抗体。6个月龄后,IgM的检出频率逐渐降低,RIA更高的灵敏度优势更加明显:60份标本中有17份通过RIA呈阳性,其中11份通过IF呈阴性。对全血清进行RIA检测似乎是一种经济、特异且灵敏的检测先天性风疹中IgM抗体的方法,当抗体滴度较低时具有特别的价值。